Rejection [A Bensler Fan Fic]

One

"What do you mean, we are done? Olivia, I want to be with you! We have our whole lives ahead of us for you to hate me, but at least do it as my partner!" Elliot yelled as Olivia stomped away from him. This had been the second time Olivia had stopped seeing Elliot. She was truly done this time, and Elliot could see that was true when he looked into her eyes.

"I'm done trying to date you, Elliot Stabler! You cheated on me and then lied to me about it! Twice! I thought you loved me! But instead you won't even say those words to me, let alone commit at all to what we have!"

"Olivia-" Elliot started, but Olivia stopped him as she turned around and stared him down.

"Brandy of all people, El. Brandy. The girl that has picked on me my whole life. From preschool to senior year... nothing has changed! You just keep doing dumb things, Brandy being one of them! So please, leave me alone. Leave me alone and tell Brandy that she won. That she doesn't have to keep twisting the knife." Olivia sniffled. She ran her hands over her face before turning again and escaping from the gym and out into the parking lot.

Elliot stared at the open door as tears burned his eyes. He hated to hear Olivia so upset, but he knew that she had to right to be angry. She had the right to hate him, especially since he did sleep with the girl who made Olivia's existence a living hell.

"God, I'm so stupid." Elliot mumbled as he raked his hands through his hair.

///

Olivia didn't speak to anyone when she got home. She just ran to her bedroom and threw herself onto her bed. She sobbed into her pillow as she tried to figure out how things went so wrong. How she could trust Elliot enough to date him twice, even after he hurt her before. She loved him, but he didn't seem to love her. And if he did, he never told her.

"Liv?" Olivia's step brother, Matthew, asked after opening her bedroom door.

"Matty, go away." Olivia sobbed as she kept her face buried in her pillows.

"Why are you crying? Did something happen at school again? I will-"

"Matthew Douglas Greene, get out!" Olivia screamed as she sat up quickly and grabbed her teddy bear before throwing it at her brother.

"Hey! Why are we yelling?" Serena asked quickly as she rushed upstairs and to where her kids were fighting.

"Something's wrong with her." Matthew sighed before he turned and walked from the room. He leaned against the wall in the hallway, but only so he could hear what was causing Olivia to cry. Why she seemed so pissed off.

"Babe, what's wrong?" Serena frowned as she walked towards her daughter. She sank down onto the edge of her daughter's bed before reaching and caressing her short brown hair.

"I don't wanna talk. So leave me alone." Olivia spat.

"Don't use that tone with me, Olivia. You know better than to be short with me. So tell me what's wrong." Serena sighed.

"I'm never going to talk to Elliot again. You better support that."

"Liv-" Serena started, but Olivia shook her head. She climbed off her bed before quickly starting to grab all the things that she had received from Elliot.

"Hey, slow down!" Serena exclaimed before grabbing her daughter's arms and pulling her away from the pictures, sweatshirts, and stuffed animals. 

"HE SLEPT WITH HER!" Olivia screamed as she tried to pull her arms from her mother's grip.

"What? Elliot? Who did he sleep with?" Serena asked quickly as Matthew ran past the door and towards the stairs. He was going to find Elliot, while his step-mother tried to calm down Olivia.

"He slept with Brandy! He has been cheating on me with her... and I saw them."

"Oh, Liv." Serena whispered.

"He told me that we were going to wait till marriage... we were wearing purity rings as a promise to each other! I love him and I honestly thought he was going to be my husband one day! But I was so dumb and believed that he was being faithful to me! And of course it was with Brandy! The same fucking girl that always picks on me and shoves me... the one that promised to make my life a living hell since the day she met me. This is beyond unforgiveable."

///

Elliot had just gotten home from baseball practice when his name was yelled. Elliot turned around slowly, but regretted it instantly. Matthew, even though he was younger, smaller, and shorter than Elliot, he still managed to hurt Elliot. He kneed him as hard as he could in his privates before punching Elliot in the nose.

"You really messed with the wrong girl! My sister doesn't deserve to be fucked with!" Matthew yelled, as Elliot groaned from where he laid on his driveway.

"Matt-" Elliot started, but Matthew shook his head.

"You slept with Brandy? Why the fuck would you do that?!" Matthew screamed.

"I didn't mean to hurt your sister, I swear! I just got caught up with Brandy!" Elliot huffed as he finally pushed himself off the ground. He stood well over six inches over Matthew, but Elliot was still a little scared of his ex's younger brother.

"You were in a relationship with my sister, but still proceeded to sleep with the girl that has told her to kill herself many times. The one who seems to enjoy making Olivia cry. How many times did you cheat on Olivia before she walked in on you and Brandy?"

"It only happened a few times... I thought that if I didn't let Olivia find out, that it wouldn't be a big deal. I'm sorry. Can you see if she'd take me back?" Elliot asked as he wiped some blood off his face.

"You must be super stupid if you think Olivia will ever take your cheating ass back." Matthew huffed.