The Girl Nextdoor

The Truth // 4

"Come on then, princess! Spit it out, or else you know what will happen." She demanded, raising her hands.

"Just give me a second," Nick said, still trying to catch his breath.

Noel grew impatient, crawling over towards Nick about to tickle him again. 

"WAIT!" Yelled Nick who giggled at the thought of being tickled. "If you want to know so bad, then fine. I didn't like it at first but then it grew on me and I began to get used to it. I liked the feeling of being treated like the girl in a relationship, it felt comforting and made me happy."

Nick rubbed his eyes as they began to form droplets of water. Noel cuddled close to Nick, holding him gently in her arms and stroking his head.

"Princess, I'm so sorry for doing this to you. If I had known this would have made you upset, I would have never tried to persuade you." Noel said with her voice slightly breaking.

Nick's tears began to slow down as she continued to comfort him, continuously giving him a supply of kisses.

"I need to be honest with you," said Noel. "I like you a lot, more than a friend."

"Well, I think I already knew that considering what we did last night." Joked Nick.

"Right, so does this mean we're a thing?" Asked Noel.

"A what?" Teased Nick.

"You know what I'm trying to say!" Noel said rolling her eyes.

"Nope, no clue." He replied.

"A couple..." She muttered.

"Didn't hear that." Nick teased again.

"A couple!" She yelled.

Nick nodded his head and Noel gently grabbed his head and pulled it towards hers as she gave him a passionate kiss.

"I have a proposition." Said Noel, releasing the kiss. "Considering we are a couple now, I believe it is fit that I will be the man of the relationship, and you shall be the woman."

Nick just nodded his head again, giving a smile this time.

"Baby girl, you're so compliant. I think you like me taking the lead." Noel teased.

Nick didn't say a word, but his face began to turn red and he could feel the heat from it. Noel undressed him to just his panties and bra and pinned him on her bed, her hands gripping his wrists. Nick felt his heart begin to speed up.

Noel, still holding Nick in place, lowered her head towards his and before he could let out a word she said with a smirk, "Babygirl, be good and stay silent." Noel continued to approach Nick, kissing him slowly for a few minutes. Still holding him, she made her way down the feminized body of his, making her way to his crotch. She paused, then flipped him to his back.

"Stay like this, if you move then there will be consequences, princess." She said turning his head to give him a quick kiss.

Nick stayed in this position and eventually felt something being applied to his butt. He then felt a tight squeeze as he let out an accidental moan with pleasure. Noel giggled, continuing to squeeze his butt with each time Nick let out a moan. He was completely lost in the moment, he hadn't even realised that he was moaning like a girl. Noel was loving every second of this and tried to drag it on as long as she could.

After a while, Noel finally stopped squeezing, giving Nick time to breathe, who was eventually letting out louder moans each time. He was on his stomach, so he couldn't see where Noel had gone, but she eventually returned with some object in her hand.

"Stay still babygirl." She seductively said, starting to squeeze his butt again. Eventually, she stopped and inserted what seemed to be a stick into his butt. He let out a moan before realising what it was.

"Hold on-" Nick said, trying to refuse.

"Babygirl, just let it happen. It's so obvious you're enjoying this. You've been moaning all this time and you probably haven't even realised, you were probably too into it that you didn't notice you've been moaning just like a girl. You even moaned just now when I put it in you." She argued. 

Noel had a very good point. Should Nick just allow this to happen? He hadn't complained about anything and even admitted to enjoying dressing up earlier, but was he ready to have sex like a girl? Nick wondered if it was true that he was moaning like a girl... Maybe he was truly too into it to realise.

Noel assumed Nick wasn't going to refuse and continued where she left off. She reinserted the dildo into his butt, causing him to moan in pleasure. She giggled, "See I told you!!"

Nick didn't say a word but felt his face turn red. Noel continued doing this, increasing in speed and how far in she went. Nick began to moan faster and louder, feeling pleasure with each thrust. He accidentally cried out "Oh, yes!"

Noel paused for a moment before continuing to go even faster, causing Nick to continue yelling out between each breath he could. It felt so good, he didn't even notice.

She finally finished, allowing Nick to regain his breath.

"You're such a cute girl, Nicole." Noel teased. "Did you notice yourself moaning and calling out? You seemed to enjoy it quite a lot."

"I did not!" Nick denied while blushing. "Okay maybe I did, but it isn't like I want a real one in me. I only like doing it with you, I don't want to do this with a boy."

"Awww, I won't tease you about it but it is true!" Noel said giving him a kiss. "I love you, princess."

"I love you too," Nick replied.

Noel loved how Nick had become this shy girl who let her dominate him. She felt as if she liked him as a girl more than she did as a boy.

It was coming to the end of their Sunday evening, so to end it they got into the shower together.

"So about earlier, did you like what happened?" Noel asked.

"I already told you... I just don't want anyone else doing that with me. Only you." He replied looking down at his feet.

"Babygirl, I would never let anyone else do that. I couldn't do that to you. You're my babygirl and only mine." She said comforting him and lifting his head back up to give him a kiss. 

What Noel told him was true. She didn't want anyone else to have him because she really liked him and could never do that to him. Although she thought it would have been nice to see him give a blowjob or take it in his butt by another guy, she still could never do that to him. She truly loved him too much.

After their shower, they dried off and Noel handed Nick a pair of pink panties and a bra. She told him she would like him to wear it underneath his clothes if he wanted. Nick nodded his head and smiled, then slipped it on. Noel got behind Nick to help strap the bra.

She stepped back to take a look at him before smiling and grabbing his butt causing him to let out a gentle moan.

"Have these too," Noel said handing him 2 more sets of lingerie, the red floral dress, a white skirt and a pink shoulderless top.

Nick smiled and hugged her with appreciation. He proceeded to put on his clothes from the other day and went to leave.

"Goodbye babygirl," said Noel.

"Bye, I'll miss you," Nick replied even though they lived close by.

The two kissed each other goodbye as Nick began to make his way home. As Nick rang the bell, he was greeted by his Mom and his sister who were both smiling.

"Had a nice time with Noel?" They both asked in unison.

A confused look formed on Nick's face before realising they knew what they had been up to.

"I hope you used protection as I told you to," His Mom scolded.

Nick didn't say a word. It hadn't even hit him that they didn't need to use protection since Nick was essentially the girl last night, but his family didn't need to know that.

Nick just nodded his head and made his way upstairs. He unpacked his things and remembered what he was wearing underneath and the clothes inside his bag.