Jeff the killer: Bisexual. This is because of all of his fangirls; I think he would be terrified of women in a way XD. But of course, there are reasons he does love girls, so I think he fits Bi.
Ben Drowned: Pansexual. Ben wouldn't care the gender, just the personality. It would be very important for him to find someone who treats him right, no matter the gender.
Jane the killer: Lesbian. She hates boys.
Eyeless Jack: Aromantic. EJ hasn't had good luck with love (talk about Jenny) and would probably be very uncomfortable with it.
Sally Williams: Either just Aromantic or too young to fall in love. We all know why.
Ticci Toby: Non-Binary, and Aromantic. Toby would be very uncomfortable with love and, he gives me non-Binary vibes.
Masky: Gay. Just look at him.
Hoodie: Gay. ITS THE VIBESSSS
Clockwork: Lesbian. She wouldn't love boys after her boyfriend dumped her (in her story).
Laughing Jack: Gay. He was once a walking pride flag. I feel like that could be a reason Isaac hated him at one point because, LJ was obviously gay. Then, when he turned colorless, and destroyed Isaac, he became whatever he wanted.
Bloody Painter: Straight. HE IS DATING JUDGE ANGELS AND IT IS A FACT NOT A HEADCANON MY PEOPLE.
Judge Angels: Straight. Judge Angels was created by yaguyi (Minister) She was 15 years old in her story. Her role is "The Judges of Chaos". She's dating a man named The Bloody Painter.
(Copy and pasted off the web for proof)
Puppeteer: Questioning. I feel like he wouldn't quite know his sexuality yet, but it would most likely be straight.
Slenderman: Aromantic. Bruh. He has no face; he just doesn't feel romance.
Homicidal Liu: Pansexual. He gives me the vibes. He would honestly just want a nice person. Doesn't matter the gender.
Nina the killer: straight. Must I explain?
Jason the toymaker: Demisexual. Demisexual is where you only feel sexual attraction towards people with whom they already have a strong emotional connection. Since Jason is just some lonely Yandere who needs a friend, he would only be attracted to his close friends. And yes, he does have some close friends. Which I why I kind of ship him with Candy Pop. Just my opinion.
Candy Pop: Genderfluid and Bisexual. You cannot tell me Candy Pop is not Genderfluid. Also, they give me Bi vibes.
Zero: Lesbian. She looks Lesbian, she even gives off fruitiness. LOOK AT HER:
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Nurse Ann: Aromantic. Please, have you read her story! She was killed by her husband! No way she loves anyone now.
Lazari: Too young for love. She's like what? 9? I guess she could be straight, but she is still too young for anything yet.
Lost Silver: Aromantic. Another one who just gives off those vibes.
Laughing Jill: Bisexual. She would like any gender; she gives off the fruitiness vibes yet again.
A/N: I feel like I am missing someone very important, if so comment and I'll add them!
