Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When you first met (throwback)

Slenderman

Once upon a time...

"ahhm...ahhm..Sally had slept already." Slender spoke.

"Okay fine,just be quiet Sally might wake up." you whispered.

Then suddenly you and Slender left the room and walked downstairs.

"hey Slendy!I have to go now.Bye!"Jeff said while waving his hand.

"leaving so soon?"Slender asked.

"well,i promised____that i will go home early.It's kinda weird but she said I have to."Jeff answered.

"Okay then. Bye!" Slender said.

Jeff had left and the two we're sitting on the couch.

"hey Slendy,do you remember how we first met?"You asked with a smile on your face.

"yeah.when you we're running in the woods while crying and suddenly you stumbled in the log and..  and-" "and fell into a mud!" you and Slender can't stop laughing.

"I'm lucky that you we're there lending a hand to help me to get up." you said while blushing.

"I'm luckier because I have found the most beautiful girl in the world that time." *he chuckled* .You two are about to kiss when suddenly someone interrupt.

"Slendy!did you see Charlie?he said he's going to the bathroom but i didn't saw him there and I saw the window was open.I wish there wasn't bad happened to him and... " Sally continues speaking and you two just sighed.

Jeff the killer

The house was dark and seems quiet.Jeff opened the door and switched the lights on.

"Suprise!"you smiled widely.

There was a cake on the table and a banner hang on the wall that says"Happy Birthday Jeff".

"wow!you made this for me?advanced huh"Jeff sat on the chair.

"well,yeah but (Ben's gf) helped me to bake the cake.That's not all,I've invited our friends to come tomorrow."you sat next to Jeff.

"so...there's another cake in the fridge?"he's excited to know.
 
"yes."you answered.

"Hooray!"he jumped in happiness.

"But this time i won't allow you to steal a slice of cake like you did before,you need to wait until tomorrow...by the way,i put a camera to be sure."you smirked.

"like i did before?"Jeff asked like he didn't know.

"yeah like the day we first met,remember?"you asked.

"umm..nope."he answered while looking at the window.

"okay i'll explain."you sighed.

"I was in the kitchen when I was taking a photo of my cake then I accidentally slipped my phone and it fell to the floor.I picked it up and I noticed there's a man standing in the other side of the table.When i looked up,you disappeared and so my slice of cake too...You left a footprints so I followed it..that's why I knew that it's you who ate the slice of my cake."you explained the whole thing.

"okay you got me."Jeff sighed in defeat.

Ben drowned

You came home tired so you lay down on the couch and wondering why there's a steak and candle on the table.

"where have you been?"Ben crossed-arms while tapping his foot on the floor.

"I'm in (Jeff's gf)'s house."you answered.

"don't you remember our deal?"Ben asked.

"what deal?"you tilted your head in confussion.

"the deal we just made when we first met."Ben replied.

"in the park?"you asked.

"no..in the-...ugh...fine i'll explain it."Ben rolled his eyes.

"You were finding the majora's mask game then i found it and said are you looking for this? then you nodded and thanked me.
When you were going to pay it,you noticed that your wallet was missing so I walked over to you and said I can pay that if you allow me to go out with you next week."Ben explained.

"it's your fault.Why didn't you say tomorrow or the next day?why it have to be next week?"you asked.

"I have to prepa-...Nevermind.Let's just go eat,the food is waiting."Ben replied.

Eyeless Jack

E.J. Puts down the phone and walked into the kitchen.

"who just called you?"you asked.

"it's (Jeff's gf)."he answered.

"so..what did she say?"you asked.

"she asked if we can come in their house tomorrow then I said why not?after all,we didn't missed any birthday party of our friends."he answered.

"yeah,even in my birthday.do you remember when we first met?"you chuckled.

"yeah i remembered when you were celebrating alone because your cousin was sick and your friend was out of town."E.J. replied.

"and I saw you in the window staring at me so i said why don't you come in? and you said huh?me? then i said yes,you! and when you entered excitedly and ran then you stepped in the banana peel and slipped so you fell into the cake which i'll never forget the look on your face."both of you laugh and laugh.

Laughing Jack

L.J. decided to scare (y/n) and make her blushed at the same time so he called Charlie to help him.Charlie came and they planned what to do.After an hour,you came home and got suprised.L.J. was holding a flowers and teddy bear.

"for you mah lady."he kneeled down.

"oh Jack you're so sweet."you blushed.

"this teddy bear was familiar...and creepy..hey Jack,where did you ge-"you're shocked,L.J. disappeared and there are candies on the floor leading to the bedroom.

You followed it and found a girl nailed on the wall and her guts were everywhere.You screamed and dropped the flowers and teddy bear.

Your eyes open widely when you saw the teddy bear was standing up and walking over to you.You screamed and ran while L.J. chuckled and thanked Charlie then said that he can go now.

You sat in the corner and hugged your knees while crying.L.J. comforted you.

"Boo!"you chuckled.

L.J. was shocked.

"Got cha!you were the one whos suprised.I heard you and Charlie planning about this."you laugh.

"but i like the teddy bear part though,it reminds me of the day we first met."you finished.

"so..you're not angry?"L.J. asked.

"ofcourse not."you answered.

"I remembered when we were in the carnival,i was trying to win the teddy bear prize and you said want help? and i said no thanks without looking at you and tried to concentrate to the game.You played and won the teddy bear and you said for you my sweet darling and i thanked you and-"L.J. cut you.

"and you blushed!"L.J. finished.

"no i didn't!"you threw a pillow into L.J.

You two began pillow fighting.

~thank you for reading!~