Who is Marley Rose?: A Supergirl and Glee Crossover (One shot Series)

Break-Up

Summary: Before Marley (Kara) and Jake broke up she revealed to him that Marley wasn't her real name, and that Millie wasn't her real mother. Despite Jake asking, Marley (Kara) would still not tell him her real name. Or even why she was using a different name. This takes place after Marley (Kara) and Jake break-up and to get revenge he decides to disclose that information in front of all of Glee Club. How will they react?

Marley wipes her tears as she enters the Glee room after school. She and Jake had just broken up after she found out that he cheated on her with Bree. As she takes her seat next to Unique, Jake stands up.

"Marley and I broke up, and since she refuses to acknowledge me and my many apologies for what I did— what I did is none of your business by the way. I've decided that if she can't trust me," Jake says with quotations around the trust. "Then why should I keep her secret and let you guys keep on trusting her."

Marley inhales deeply, already knowing where this was going, and stands up to leave. But before she can exit Jake grabs her arm. "Where do you think you're going? Huh?"

"Anywhere but here." She responds, ripping her arm out of his grip.

"Marley I can't let you leave before Glee club is over without a note from your mother." Mr. Shue says. "And Jake, if she trusted you with a secret then you should just keep it to yourself."

"No he shouldn't," Tina argues. "If he thinks that we shouldn't trust her then there must be a good reason behind it."

"Come to Unique." Unique motions to Marley. "I'll always trust you no matter what. You've been nothing but kind and supportive the entire time that I've known you."

Marley smiles, "You have no idea how much that means to me."

Kitty points at Jake and shakes her head, "Well? Get on with it!"

"Marley isn't her real name, nor is Mille her real mom." Jake says.

The entirety of Glee Club gasps.

"Marley is this true?" Mr. Shue demands.

Marley looks at Jake. "I entrusted you with that information. My family kept telling me not to tell anybody, but I told you because I loved you. Like I thought that you loved me."

"Marley you do realized that going to a school, or anywhere official for that matter, under a fake name is illegal, right?" Blaine asks her, not out of malice, but out of concern for the younger girl.

She doesn't respond.

"What even is your real name?!" Kitty commands.

Marley shallows, "I— I can't tell you that."

"Why?" Tina inquires. "Are you hiding something?"

"I wouldn't say that, no."

Unique hugs her, "Y'all, I'm sure that our girl here has a good reason. Puckerman 2.0 here on the other hand sure doesn't have a good reason to say anything about this information that she trusted him with."

"Thank you." Marley states. "But I have to go now. I can't stay here anymore now that you all know. As much as I wish that I could, they just wouldn't ever allow it."

"Who is they?" Artie asks her.

"I can't say."

"Can't or won't?!" Sam exclaims.

"Both." She says, pulling her phone out.

"Who are you calling?" Mr. Shue questions.

"None of your business."

"I'm your teacher, that makes it my business." He retorts.

"Not anymore you're not— And no, it doesn't."

She dials a number and the club hears somebody answer the phone.

"They know," Is all that Marley says.

"Who knows?!" They hear a voice demand on the other end.

"Glee Club."

The person's voice lowers. "Do you want me to pick you up? I only have one last college class today, and I can call in sick."

"No," Marley responds. "I can get home myself. Can you let Eliza know what happened and that I'm on my way home? I'll let Millie know myself."

"Sure. Love you." Is all that's heard on the other line before the dial tone lets them all know that the person hung up.

"Goodbye." Marley says to them, before leaving the McKinley classroom. The next day she doesn't show up, and days turn into weeks, and weeks slowly turn into months.

"She really isn't coming back, is she?" Blaine wonders aloud to the others.

"Nope." Unique says sadly. "Do you think that we'll ever find her again?"

"I don't know." Tina says, looking down.

"We treated her horribly." Kitty states.

Unique glares at her.

"You know what?" Ryder states. "We'll find her whether or not it takes months or years."

The others agree and there starts the long journey to find her.