How Could You? Five x Reader (rewrite ver)

1

"Come on y/n! Hurry up! These bad guys aren't going to stop themselves!" Klaus yelled at me.

"I'm coming, I'm coming! Wait up!" I called, rushing over to Klaus and Ben, who were waiting for me at the end of the hallway. We rushed down the stairs before running over to the rest of my siblings, getting there just in time.

"Nice to see you showed up," Five whispered. I glared at him before returning my attention to Dad.

"...and I expect you all to be on your upmost behavior, no fooling around, Number Four" he said, muttering the last part. We all heard it and started laughing a bit. "Alright, lets go," Dad said, leading us outside.

After we finished defeating the robbers at the bank, we were lead outside to be greeted by a crowd of fans and press. Dad always told us to never answer their questions, but just to stand there and smile. I was stood next to Ben. However, I kept my distance because he was covered in blood. "You ok, Ben?" I asked.

"Y-Yeah, just really uncomfortable right now," Ben sighed.

"Me too," I replied, "I mean, this attention is flattering, but I honestly rather be at home right now." Ben agreed, then went back to staring at his feet.

Once we got home, I immediately went upstairs, just like everyone does after a mission. I was about to step into my room when I heard, "Hey, y/n, want to join us in Allison's room? We're playing truth or dare!"

"Sure, Klaus," I said, following him into Allison's room. Everyone was already there, except for Five. "Where's Five?" I asked, sitting down next to Vanya.

"Right here," said Five, appearing right next to me. I jumped when he responded, while everyone just laughed.

"Five! You have to stop doing that before you kill me!" I exclaimed, clearly annoyed.

"You know you love it," Five smirked.

"Anyways, who wants to go first?" Allison asked.

"I will!" Klaus exclaimed, "Ok, Diego, truth or dare?"

"I choose dare, I'm no wuss, unlike Luther," Diego said while Luther glared at him.

"I dare you to throw one of your knives without thinking where it goes," Klaus dared.

"Klaus! Do you know how dangerous that is? He could kill someone!" Luther exclaimed.

"Watch me," Diego smirked, throwing a knife automatically. We all ducted, hoping to not get hit. Luckily, the knife only hit a wall, creating a hole.

"Diego!" Allison exclaimed, getting up and pulling the knife out of her bedroom wall.

"Sorry! It was a dare!" Diego said, "Now, my turn! Five, truth or dare?"

"I pick truth," Five said without hesitation. "Alright, if you could have anyone else's power in this room, who's would it be?" Diego asked.

"That's a tough one. I think Y/n's power would be cool to have. I'd like to read someone's mind," Five said, looking at me.

"Thanks, Five, your power is cool too," I smiled, accepting the compliment. He just smiled back, returning to the game. 'I never seen Five smile at anyone..' I heard someone think, probably Klaus.

After a few rounds, I started getting bored. "Alright guys, I'm out. I'll be in my room if you need me." I walked into my room and shut the door. I then sat on my bed and continued the book I was reading this morning.

"You're such a nerd!" Five said, appearing in my room.

"Dammit Five!" I yelled. He just laughed and lied down next to me.

"Let me see this," he said, grabbing the book from my hands. He read a page or two, and I could hear the words in his head. He then handed the book back to me. "You read too much, that book is so boring," he complained.

"At least I don't barge into people's room uninvited," I retorted.

"Touché," Five said before getting up and walking over to my desk. He looked at all the unfinished drawings I left scattered on my desk. "I like this one you did here, it kind of looks like dad, but in a deformed way," Five smiled picking up the drawing.

"You think?" I said getting up and walking over to him, "I think it looks terrible."

"Don't say that, Y/n. Here look at this one, it's great!" He said, pointing to a drawing of the courtyard outside of the academy.

"If it's so great, then take it. I don't mind," I said. He smiled, taking the drawing from the pile he was rummaging through. He teleported out of my room, only to appear back after a few seconds, the drawing out of his hands.

"So, I'll see you later? Maybe we could hang out before bedtime?" Five asked.

"I guess so. I'll go ask Ben or Klaus if they want to join us-"

"No, don't. I want it to be just the two of us," Five said interrupting me.

"Oh...I'll see you later then," I said. He nodded and teleported out of my room. I sighed and went back to my bed, opening my book again.