EyelessJack x Reader (1) - Thank you

Shut Up Jane

(Y/n) = Your Name
(Your thoughts are typed in brackets)

You looked up from your D.S and looked around the living room in the slender mansion. BEN and Jeff were busy playing Mario Kart on the wii, Laughing Jack was eating candy, Sally was playing with Smile Dog and Eyeless Jack was reading a book next to you. As for Jane she was just twirling her knife in her hand, looking at the t.v and laughing at Jeff. Hoodie and Masky were probably in the kitchen eating the cheesecake you had made for yourself. Again. Ticci Toby was also probably in the kitchen, though he would most likely be eating waffles.
" No! Come on! I was fifth! " Jeff yelled at the t.v. " Then stupid Mario came and pushed me off- " he stopped suddenly and slowly turned around to look at a grinning BEN. " BEN what character are you? " he asked venom dripping from his voice. You couldn't help but smile.
" Mario " BEN replied smiling smugly at Jeff. " Oops did I push you off the rainbow road? Did I hurt your precious little feelings? " BEN smiled at Jeff.
" Well goodbye BEN, it was nice knowing you " You smiled looking up from your DS. Jeff grinned at you and then turned back to BEN smiling evilly. It was pretty creepy to be honest.
" See? She knows what's about to happen. " Jeff smiled at BEN before jumping on him.
BEN let out a high pitched scream as Jeff tackled him to the floor. He quickly grabbed Jeff's hair and pulled hard. Jeff growled, that's right, growled, at him and took out his knife.
" GO TO SLEEP " he managed to say in between getting strangled by the little elf boy.
" Hell no! " BEN shouted. Suddenly they were pulled away by tentacles.
" What did I say about fighting in the house? " Slenderman said so calmly it was scary. (Maybe I should have intervened.... )
" (Y/n)? I thought we had agreed that you would help keep order in the mansion? " Slender questioned me. (Crap! Here comes the talk... )
" But it was so entertaining! " You said whilst pouting at the tall, tentacle guy.
Laughing Jack laughed from the couch. Whether he was laughing at what you said, or just laughing in general because that's what he does, you did not know. Slenderman sighed and turned to look at BEN and Jeff.
" You two are going to have to start getting along. Or (Y/n) will be forced to kill you. " He threatened. You nodded enthusiastically.
" Yup! " You tilted your head to the side and smiled. Jeff gave you a weird look and BEN raised an eyebrow at you.
" Umm (Y/n), you seem way too enthusiastic about it.. " E.J said most likely smiling slightly under his mask, only looking up from his book to look at you momentarily.
" (Y/n) wouldn't kill me! She loves me too much! She would probably kill Jeff though.. No offence. " BEN said shrugging his shoulders at Jeff as if apologising.
" Hey (Y/n) loves me more than you! " Jeff shouted at BEN pouting.
" Don't start an argument about this. I doubt (Y/n) likes any of you! " Sally shouted, laughing at what she said. You soon joined in on her laughter and then L.J joined in too. Slenderman sighed and walked out shaking his head. You calmed down before answering.
" That's not true! I love all of you equally! " You shouted pointing your finger at all of them in turn.
" You like someone a little more though... " Jane taunted grinning at you. Your face immediately went red and you looked down at your D.S. You could feel everyone's eyes on you. Even E.J had turned away from his dissection book to look at you. (Well, this isn't going to go well at all.)
" I- I don- " You stuttered making Jane's grin widen.
" Sure you don't. I'm willing to bet that he's in this room right now! " she exclaimed looking directly at E.J. (Damn it I just had to tell her last week didn't I? It seemed like a good idea at the time. Now I'm not so sure... Okay yes I had a tiny little crush- okay more like HUGE obsession with him, but come on! She didn't have to tell everyone!)
" Pfft I do not know what you're talking about woman! " You shouted, flinging your arms up into the air. Masky, Hoodie and Toby all walked in, startled from your shouting.
" Sure you don't (Y/n).. " she grinned winking at you. Everyone was still staring at you. (This is rather uncomfortable...) You shrunk back into the couch you were sitting on.
" Why are you staring at me?! Stop staring at me! " You shouted startling them a little. They all looked away except for Jeff.
" So.. Are you going to tell me who you like? I'm like your best friend! " He looked at you pleading with his eyes. " Please? "
" Woah! You are not her best friend! I am. " BEN said nodding in Jeff's direction.
" Pfft leave her alone! And I'm her best friend. " Sally added running over to you and sitting on your lap, making her teddy sit on her own lap.
" Will you guys stop arguing about who's her best friend?! I just want to know who she likes! " Masky shouted, shutting them all up. You looked at their expectant faces.
" Wait, you guys actually think I'm going to tell you? Hell no! I would die! " You yelled, turning to look at all of them as if that was obvious. Whilst turning, your eyes met with E.J's sockets and he quickly looked away and so did you. You were blushing like mad, and who even knew what E.J's face was like right now.
" Oh for zalgos sake! " Everyone turned to look at Jane after her outburst. " She's obviously not going to tell you so I might as well do it! " She continued. Your eyes widened and you shook your head.
" Don't you dare. " you hissed, glaring at her. She smiled at you.
" Oh trust me you'll thank me for this. " She replied winking at you. You rolled your eyes before closing them. No use trying to get her to stop, because she won't.
" So who does she like? " E.J asked. (Was that hope in his voice? No can't have been.. Ha, as if. He can't like me back. Thats what happens in bad love stories. That would never happen to me. )
" Funny you'd ask that because (Y/n) likes you! " She exclaimed pointed at E.J. The room went silent as everyone looked at you.

A/n - So what do you guys think of the first part? Comment what you think. I'd love to hear your feedback :) Also if you liked this chapter don't forget to vote! I would appreciate it so much! Thanks :)