The episode begins with Barf Bag asking Gelatin to return a DVD of back to to avoid paying a fine, and after a bit of deliberation and a violent outburst from Barf Bag, Gelatin fearfully obliges.
He goes to the kitchen to ask Bomby of the DVD's whereabouts, only to find Bomby using the disc to cut a pizza. Gelatin grabs it from him and tries to clean it with a sponge, but he accidentally uses the abrasive side, scratching the disc up and causing him to freak out. In the ensuing panic, he accidentally drops the disc into the kitchen sink's garbage disposal, shredding it to pieces. Gelatin then decides they need to find a way to replace the DVD without their mother finding out what they have done.
First, he tries to replace the DVD with a cardboard cut-out, but the trick fails to deceive , who sends them increasingly urgent notices. Instead of facing the consequences, however, gelatin decides the next best solution is to beg for money on the street to pay off their debt, though unsurprisingly, it too fails to work (with the getting rich in the process by taking their earnings and winning the lottery).
Back at home, Gelatin and Bomby search for jobs in the newspaper, eventually settling on a job in cosmetics for make-up testing. The two go in a booth that manually applies the make-up, but Gumball suffers an allergic reaction, horrifying the .
They return home once more, where Gelatin discovers a bunch of more letters from Laser Video. He realizes that he and Bomby are in trouble and he tells Bomby that they have to hide the letters before Barf Bag gets home. Then, they get a call from her who suspects something is amiss when the two try to assure her that the situation is under control, she suspects that they are lying and tells them she is coming home. Panicked, they double down on one last resort, however degrading and unlikely to work it may be. Right as Barf Bag arrives and discovers the letters from Laser Video and becomes enraged, Gelatin and Bomby run away from the house. A chase ensues, with Barf Bag trying to chase them down to reprimand them, but it ends when she accidentally slams into a wall.
Gelatin and Bomby arrive at Laser Video and hand over the DVD, which turns out to be a homemade version of Alligators on a Train, featuring cardboard cut-outs and the pair's names exclusively in the credits. Unconvinced, Lollipop orders Gelatin and Bomby to return the original DVD immediately. Upon hearing this, Gelatin and Bomby cry and confess what happened to the DVD and beg Lollipop not to tell Barf Bag, who turns out to be right behind them. She pays off the fine of twenty-five dollars for the lost DVD, telling Gelatin and Bomby that she still loves them no matter what they do. Unfortunately, she fails to account for the late fee on the DVD, totaling seven hundred dollars, and the episode ends with a freeze-frame of them running away from Lollipop to avoid paying it off.
