[P.E.T AWARDS 2023] - || CLOSED || Kpop awards

-BEST BOOK COVER || RESULTS-

Judge: Haea_BTS

Secondary Judge: Yeontanaaaaaaa (Since the reviews are a little bit small, I'll give you a second review too.)

I have altered some of the final scores too, just because the reviews were too short so it wasn't clear enough, so the final scores are actually from me. Some of the reviews by Haea_BTS were mixed up, so just read the review below it instead.

Final placement:

1. Seong_Grace - 10/10

2. Yeong_fictions - 9.5/10

3. Bangtan_cute_person - 9/10

1. yeong_fictions - It's really detailed and well made. Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: This is a great cover! It fits with the mood, and the highlights are great! The background is a perfect fit with the characters and the raindrops were a good add-on. However, for its lighting, the contour and highlights are a little bit too much, and the font is a little hard to read from a distance. But, it stands out among other covers. 9.5/10.

2. Seong_Grace - It's really beautiful and you also give a lot of attention to the title because it's really big. -Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: This is absolutely beautiful. All the highlights and contour and everything about it; the roses, the window in the back, the colours and even the font were all visually pleasing. The highlights give a heavenly glow to Jungkook, enticing the reader at first glance. One of the best book covers I have ever seen. 10/10.

3. Bangtan_cute_person - It's beautiful, but maybe you can add more detail to the background. - Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: It's a great cover, I love the different use of the highlights and the layers and every single composition. The font has a sort of a hybrid between modern and vintage style and the picture itself is visually pleasing. It's simple and effective, but I wish there was slightly more focus on the flowers, rather than having so many highlights on his hair, which isn't the centre point. 9/10.

4. shinaari - This one is personally one of my favorites. The theme matches with the name, and the colors are very nice. - Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: I can see the effort, with the font being there and everything. However, there isn't really any cropped factor and the font is a little bit off and thin if you look at it from a distance. 4/10.

5. Riyabangtanff - [OUTDATED REVIEW] It's good, but the name of the book is not there. Also, it's pretty plain. Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: It's a good cover, and the title does stand out, being red and neon colours in contrast to the dark black and grey of the picture. I like it's simplicity and it fits well with the book. But, its missing the flavour, something that sets it apart from the others. 8/10.

6. banosri554 - This one gives you a little teaser about the story by the photo and is really beautiful. Haea_BTS

Yeontanaaaaaaa 's review: It's a good face swap, I must say. It looks like it was taken from pinterest or google. It's simple, but the contrast is too high and there is no type of title, credits or any add ons from the author. A little bit cheap. 6/10.

7. Since ShriparnaO 's review was missing, this one is from me:

It's simple and effective: the colour scheme is aesthetic, and the title font suits really well. The page rip in the middle gives off a somewhat happy but also empty vibe, which completely goes hand-in-hand with the story (the barcode was a pretty funny add-on too). I just feel like the two pieces of font don't seem to go seamlessly together; it's almost a little bit off-putting. Also, it's a little bit grainy and the contrast is a little bit too high, seeing that it has add ons in the background of the picture in light colours. Overall, it's decent. 8.5/10.