The Error of Subordinationism

Eli Kittim

Ontological Subordinationism

The theological literature defines Subordinationism as comprising hierarchical rankings amongst the persons of the Trinity, thus signifying an ontological subordination of both the Son and the Spirit to the Father. The word ontological refers to "being." Although some of the ante-Nicene fathers supported subordinationism, this doctrine was eventually condemned as heretical by the Post-Nicene fathers:

"Athanasius opposed subordinationism, and
was highly hostile to hierarchical rankings
of the divine persons. It was also opposed
by Augustine. Subordinationism was
condemned in the 6th century along with
other doctrines taught by Origen.
Epiphanus writing against Origen attacked
his views of subordinationism." — wiki

Calvin also opposed subordinationism:

"In his Institutes of the Christian Religion,
book 1, chapter 13 Calvin attacks those in
the Reformation family who while they
confess 'that there are three [divine]
persons' speak of the Father as 'the
essence giver' as if he were 'truly and
properly the sole God'. This he says,
'definitely cast[s] the Son down from his
rank.' This is because it implies that the
Father is God in a way the Son is not.
Modern scholars are agreed that this was a
sixteenth century form of what today is
called, 'subordinationism'. Richard Muller
says Calvin recognised that what his
opponents were teaching 'amounted to a
radical subordination of the second and
third persons, with the result that the Father
alone is truly God.' Ellis adds that this
teaching also implied tritheism, three
separate Gods." — wiki

The Eastern Orthodox position is yet another form of subordinationism that has asserted the Monarchy of the Father to this day:

"According to the Eastern Orthodox view, the
Son is derived from the Father who alone is
without cause or origin." — wiki

The Catholic Church, however, is overtly antithetical to the subordinationism doctrine:

"Catholic theologian John Hardon wrote that
subordinationism 'denies that the second
and third persons are consubstantial with
the Father. Therefore it denies their true
divinity.' "— wiki

In theology proper, unlike ontological subordination, there is also the doctrine of "economic subordination" in which the Son and the Holy Spirit play subordinate roles in their functions, even though they may be ontologically equal to the Father. New Calvinists have been advancing this theory of late:

"While contemporary Evangelicals believe
the historically agreed fundamentals of the
Christian faith, including the Trinity, among
the New Calvinist formula, the Trinity is one
God in three equal persons, among whom
there is 'economic subordination' (as, for
example, when the Son obeys the Father)." — wiki

According to the Oxford Encyclopedia, the doctrine of Subordinationism makes the Son inferior to the Father, and the Holy Spirit inferior to the Son. It reads thusly:

"Subordinationism means to consider Christ,
as Son of God, as inferior to the Father.
This tendency was strong in the 2nd- and
3rd-century theology. It is evident in
theologians like Justin Martyr, Tertullian,
Origen, Novatian, and Irenaeus. Irenaeus,
for example, commenting on Christ's
statement, 'the Father is greater than I'
(John 14:28), has no difficulty in
considering Christ as inferior to the Father.
... When Origen enlarged the conception of
the Trinity to include the Holy Spirit, he
explained the Son as inferior to the Father
and the Holy Spirit as inferior to the Son.
Subordination is based on statements
which Jesus made, such as (a) that 'the
Father is greater than I' (John 14:28); (b)
that, with respect to when the day of
Judgment will be, 'of that day or hour no
one knows, not even the angels in heaven,
nor the Son, but the Father alone' (Mark
13:32), and that He spoke of God as
somebody else (Mark 11:18)." — wiki