Eyes Don't Lie ✩ Jenna Ortega (G!P)

XXXIII

| Jenna's POV |

Liked by jennaortega, conangray, and 994,678 others
noty/n_l/n: I DONT KNOW ABOUT YOU, BUT IM FEELING 22 🎂🤍🥳

jennaortega: have the absolute best birthday ever, my love 💖
\_ noty/n_l/n: thank you baby 🤭

conangray: HAPPY BDAY GIRLY 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
liked by creator

oliviarodrigo: ITS MY BESTIES BDAY! OH YEAH! HAPPY BDAY HONEY ❤️‍🔥
liked by creator

Comments have been limited

—————

I hugged Y/N from behind, kissing the spot behind her ear as she slid the necklace that I gave her early on. "Mm hi." She giggled, turning in my arms to kiss me.

"Happy birthday." I grinned as I whispered those words in her soft lips. "I have so many surprises in store for you today." I ran my hands up and down her sides, slightly biting my lip

Y/N smiled brightly up at me, looping her arms around my shoulders. "I'm so excited. Billie said she's able to fly out with Finneas for my party tonight, Olivia is coming with Conan and Madison, Emma said she'd come." Her fingers danced across my shoulder blades and chest. "Melissa and them are coming too. Gracie as well, I can't wait to see her again."

She's so adorable when she rambles.

"Is there anything else you think we need for the party?" I asked and sat on the bed, watching her hold up the new dresses I bought her up to her body. "More booze, snacks, cups?"

"I do need balloons." She turned to me. "Also, which dress would look better on me tonight? The red or black one?"

"Black is absolutely sexy on you." I stood up, kissing her lips softly before I pulled away to grab my keys off her dresser. "I'll go get your balloons."

"Bring me back home a candy bar, please!" Y/N shouted from her bedroom as I made my way to the door.

"I will, baby." I chuckled and left. I got in my car, driving to the nearest Party City. I picked out a few balloons that I thought she'd like, some of them were brightly colored yet simple at the same time. I remembered what Y/N said and grabbed her a candy bar before going to the register.

"Well, well, well." After grabbing my receipt, I turned around and immensely rolled my eyes when I saw Sam. "Look what the cat dragged in."

"I forgot you worked here." I grumbled under my breath, smiling forcibly at the cashier who helped me as I grabbed the balloons, making my way to the exit.

"Who are these for?" Sam's hand harshly placed itself on my chest, her eyes dark and cold. It made my heart race, I was happy we aren't together anymore so it wouldn't happen again, but that doesn't mean it's impossible for it to happen.

"If you must know, they're for Y/N. You know, my girlfriend of almost 6 weeks now." I emphasized to piss her off. Sam clenched her fists, glancing at her coworkers who were occupied with other customers.

"What do you see in her, huh? She's not even pretty so she must be good at sex?"

Is this bitch serious?

"No, it's not just the sex, you whore. She's absolutely gorgeous inside and out, she has a better personality than you ever did and at least she actually cares about me." I spat in her face, watching her eyes darken more. I went to leave but I stopped and said this without looking at her, "And at least my girl knows what the word 'no' means."

With that, I immediately left the store, almost running to my car. I knew that if she didn't work there, she'd be chasing me right out the door, banging on my car window like some crazy witch.

I drove off and buckled my seatbelt up in the process. I haven't felt this scared in my life.

—————

"Oh, baby, right on time!"

Y/N's house was a little packed with our friends all around the house. The smell of booze filled the air. "Hey." I said, barely above a whisper.

Y/N immediately took her attention off of her party and pulled me into her bedroom. She shut the door and cradled my head in her arms. "What's wrong? You seem upset."

"I ran into Sam at Party City." I mumbled out sadly. Y/N pulled my face out of her chest, giving me sympathetic eyes.

"What did she do, baby?" Her hands gently stroked my cheeks, making me feel so at home and safe in her embrace.

"She didn't do anything, but she did say some things." I sniffled, trying to hold back the tears since it was her birthday and I didn't want to be a burden with my crap. "It's okay, I'll be fine."

"Hey, if you think you're going to be a burden, then stop." Y/N dragged me over to the bed, pushing me to the sit down while she straddled me waist, holding my head. "You're not a burden and I want to hear all about your problems because I want to help you, baby."

I almost cried.

"Tell me what happened, sweetie. I promise I can try and make it better." Y/N's sweet words were a greater comfort to me than I ever thought possible. She had such a sweet and genuine tone to her voice. She wasn't being manipulative or anything, not even feigning false promises.

This girl is too perfect.

"Well-" I cleared my throat as I rested my head on her shoulder, sighing softly and relaxing when her hand ran through my hair. "It all started when Sam and I were dating..."