Chapter 4: Caught in the Hottie Neighbor's Gaze

1 0 0
                                    

I was hanging out near the covered court by our house, enjoying the sound of the basketball game. My older brother, Nathaniel, was playing, and I could see Archie and Peter, one of our neighbors, also joining in. 

Peter was someone I had admired for a long time—he was tall, moreno, gym-fit, and just had this effortless charm about him. He looked like a model, and the way he played basketball only made him look even more attractive.Peter's best friend, Manny, was also there, tall and handsome with a rich vibe. Despite coming from a well-off family, he and Peter had been roommates for a while, both working as salesmen in a mall. I had always envied the way they carried themselves—confident and charismatic. 

 As I sat by the court, watching them play, Nathaniel noticed me and made a teasing comment to Peter, saying that I was his "biggest supporter." I could feel my cheeks flush with embarrassment, but I tried to brush it off, pretending like I didn't care.The game ended, and I couldn't help but watch as the guys took off their shirts, revealing their sweaty, toned bodies. I tried to keep my eyes off them, but Peter and Manny, with their gym-fit physiques, were hard to ignore. 

From the corner of my eye, I could see Nathaniel and Archie whispering, clearly enjoying teasing me. Peter caught their looks and smiled at me from across the court. My heart skipped a beat.When we got home, Nathaniel and Archie started teasing me about how I looked at Peter, joking around in a way that made me even more flustered. I retorted, trying to defend myself, saying they were just jealous that they weren't as good-looking as Peter and Manny. 

Archie shot a playful jab, hinting at how I must have a lot of experience with guys, which made me uneasy. I had to change the subject quickly, so I offered to buy them some food.Later, while I was at the store buying halo-halo, I ran into Peter. We exchanged some casual conversation—he asked how old I was and what year I was in school. I told him I was a senior, and he nodded, smiling. I couldn't help but notice how his gaze lingered for a second before he looked away. My heart raced, and I felt a strange mix of excitement and nervousness. 

To my surprise, Peter paid for the food I was getting, saying I could consider it a treat. He also asked if I wanted to come by his place later and asked for my number. I gave it to him, feeling a rush of happiness. When I got home, I handed the food to Nathaniel and Archie before heading to my room. I couldn't resist sneaking a look at Peter's Facebook profile, admiring his photos and his posts. I smiled to myself, hoping I'd get to see him again soon. 

 Around 6 p.m., I woke up from a nap, feeling a little more refreshed. I checked my phone and saw a message from Peter asking if I was busy. I replied that I had just woken up, and he invited me over to his house. 

 When I arrived at Peter's place, he greeted me with a smile and invited me to his room. I was nervous but tried to act casual. We started talking about basketball—something I was passionate about. I kept telling him how much I loved the sport, and Peter listened intently. I noticed that the other bed in the room was empty—Manny wasn't there. I asked about him, and Peter casually mentioned that Manny was with his girlfriend and that they had just broken up. 

 We continued chatting, but I could sense a shift in the mood. Peter's energy felt a bit more teasing, and I started to feel a little nervous. It wasn't anything obvious, but there was a certain way he was looking at me. I wasn't sure how to handle it. I tried to laugh it off but found myself feeling a bit uneasy, unsure of what to do. 

Peter moved over on the couch, patting the space next to him. I sat down, our thighs brushing against each other. I felt a jolt of heat surge through me, and I tried to ignore the way my heart raced in my chest.We started talking again, but this time it felt different. There was a palpable sense of awareness between us—an understanding that we were both fully aware of the attraction. 

I could feel the tension building with each word, each glance.Peter leaned in closer, his hand resting on my thigh, sending a shock of electricity through my body. I swallowed hard, unsure of what to do next. I started asking him about his relationship and he said that he just broke up with his girlfriend and was feeling horny. 

I felt nervous as he intentionally rubbed his bulge while sitting in bed. I felt my heart racing as Peter smiled back and then lowered his shorts showing his underwear with a hard manhood tracing and he continued to stroke it. Peter asked me if I was a virgin and if I had any experience sucking a big dick.I was speechless but just nodded then Peter finally revealed his long hard dick and I felt scared but focused as I watch him while he carefully stroke every inch of it. It was so big and hard. 

To my surprise, he stood up removed his clothing, and then moved closer. "Suck me" he demanded. My mind was telling me to say no and leave but my body obeyed. I opened my mouth as he moved his long hard cock inside me and I started sucking it. I tried to take it in slowly but he suddenly tried to shove it in deep but it was too big, making me choke. "Sorry. I'll be gentle this time." He said.I gave it another try and this time it was so smooth and my mouth was enjoying every inch of him. 

Then Peter guided me to his bed and then we lie down and asked me to undress, touching my butt, saying it was so cute. Then he slapped it hard while I was focused on sucking him more passionately making him moa. Then we switched positions and I was resting my back in the bed and now Peter was positioned on top of me and he started to hold my head as he tried to mouth fuck me slowly letting me take his long hard dick deeper reaching my throat and making me gag.

 "Just relax," he asked me while he thrust his throbbing cock inside my lips while finding his rhythm I thought it was all that but Peter had other plans. He made me switch my position now lying face-front exposing my butt and he started to lick my hole and spread my cheeks open. "Uhhh wait stop." I moaned. But he continued to play with my hole and he spit saliva between my cheeks and put his finger inside making me scream. But I felt the pain suddenly shift to intense pleasure and he opened my legs wider. 

"Relax your body and just concentrate. Don't fight it." he finally slides his hard dick inside my hole.It was so big and I felt it stretching my hole. "Ahhh it's so big. Please stop." But he didn't move at first and just kissed my shoulders and ears making me moan again. And then I felt his full length moving slowly inside me going deeper and thrusting gently with a slow rhythm. 

I was surprised as my body started to go with the rhythm and I felt my hole taking it all in."Ahh, good boy. Yeah just like that." he moved thrusting harder and faster, making a clamping sound as it pressed against my cheeks. "Ohh Peter. Fuck me harder. Ahh". I was feeling intense pleasure building up as every thrust sent shockwaves in my body.Then Peter moved faster and deeper making us both moan loudly. I felt him moving more aggressively as he covered my mouth while he moved harder and faster until he finally reached his climax. "Fuck I'm going to... come. Ahhhhh." 

I felt Peter's hard dick pulsing inside my hole squirting his load until he collapses on top of me all sweaty and breathing fast."'That was amazing. You have a nice tight pussy." he said. Then he withdrew his dick inside me and we lay in bed together cuddling. Then I told him that I needed to go home so we finally dressed up and I walked home, feeling some pain but I tried to hide it until I reached his room. I can officially say that I am no longer a virgin and my first time was with my crush. 

Julien's Sex DiaryWhere stories live. Discover now