Creepypasta Stories

EJ X Reader: Special Prize

You were working late one night at the hospital looking over some patients charts. " Looks to be another long night huh ___?" you co worker Mindy asked from across the reception desk she sat at. " Ye..yeah it will be. Have you heard in the news about the kidney killer? This guy in a blue masks kills people by only taking their kidneys. Well one at first, and then the other another night. It's sort of disgusting." you say, as you move some of your (h/c) strands of hair behind your ear. Mindy chuckles. " Yeah that is sickening, I heard the killer not only takes the kidneys; but eats them as well, once the one kidney is done he comes for the other." she said in a weird tone which made you cringe a bit. " Also they say he will also take your eyes as souvenirs since he has none. Eyeless Jack is his name, and taking kidneys is his game." Mindy adds on which made you cringe even more. " Mindy cut it o..." you started to say when you heard a loud smashing sound coming near the organ freezer. " W...what was that Mindy?" you asked, as Mindy got up, and went to the doorway. " Stay here ____ I'll go check it out. If I'm not back in 20 minutes...call for help." she said, as she headed out the door, and down the hall leaving you alone in the office space.

You continued to work on your assignments when you heard a blood chilling scream of Mindy coming down the hall. " MINDY!" you screamed, as you got up to go help her; but suddenly something hit you hard over the head, and you blacked out. You awoke a few hours later to the sound of movement, and what also sounded like a beast gobbling up it's prey. You sat up only to feel pain shot up your left side. You glance down, and you notice your left side is stitched up, and you're laying in a small puddle of blood.

" Wh...what happened?" you ask yourself when you look over, and see someone hunched over the body of your co worker, and friend. " M..Mindy! Get away from her you..." you started to shout; but then went silent, as the person turned to look at you, and you saw they were wearing a blue mask. " Silence girl. I'm almost done with her. Then I will vanish. Don't tell anyone I've been here or else...your other kidney get's eaten right now!" he said, as he stood up, and walked over towards you before leaning down, and moving his mask up a bit, he licked some blood off your face before he knocked you out again.

More time has passed; but this time you awoken in your own room. You glance around to make sure you were alone. You sigh when you are; but wondered exactly how you got home. " That...was Eyeless Jack...why did he show up at the hospital?" you ask yourself when you hear a knock on your door. " Come in..." you say a little frighten; but where relieved when you saw your older brother walk in. You immediately got up, and hugged him in tears. " Calm ___ everything will be fine. I'm glad you are alright. I can't say the same for Mindy. You've been given a few weeks off of work. I talked with the others, and they agreed." he told you, as you weeped into his chest. " But I saw him Drake...I saw Eyeless Jack he was the one who killed Mindy, and he took my kidney...I'm going to die next..." you said thru tears, as Drake did his best to calm you down.

" Please___ you need to calm down. You've been thru enough yesterday. Get some rest, and I will check on you later. Right now I'll go out, and get you some soup ok." he said, as he put you safely back into bed, and then headed out the door. Your ( e/c) eyes watched Drake leave, as you feared Eyeless Jack would come back for you at any minute. You looked out your balcony window, and saw it was thundering, and lighting outside, as a heavy down pour of rain began. You started to hum ( favorite song) to yourself, and close your eyes to get some more sleep. Suddenly your eyes shoot open, as you looked again out your window, and saw a large silhouette of a person standing there trying to open your window. " No...NO!" you scream, as the window is unlocked, and the wind burst open, and the person you feared would come find you again walked into your room. EJ glanced over to you, as he walked over, and gripped his hand around your throat. " I told you not to mention to anyone I was there or you saw me...now you're going to pay..." he said, as he climbed onto the bed, and straddled you.

You closed your eyes in fear of what was going to happen; but then you stopped shaking once you felt lips on top of yours. Was he actually kissing you? You were shocked at first; but then you kissed him back hoping this would make him spare you. EJ smirked into the kiss, as he ran his tongue over your bottom lip for entrance. You were scared to do it, so he reached down, and grasped one of your breasts. You gasped right away which EJ took no time in darting his tongue deep into your mouth, and exploring every inch he could find. Your body started to grow hot, and your legs shook from this passionate kiss. EJ un kissed from you, as he looks down at you. " I want you ___ I want you to only be mine...I've been watching you for 2 months now. Can you find it in your heart to be mine as well?" he asked you, as you slowly reached up to take his mask off. This motion you did startled EJ, as he jumped off the bed, and brought out his scalpel aiming it at you. You stared at his actions, and slowly got out of bed your ( f/c) nightgown flowing down to the floor.

" Eyeless Ja...No Jack...you don't have to be afraid...all I want to do is look at your face." you tell him, as you walk closer, and slowly put your hand on his which is holding the scalpel. His hand twitches a bit at the contact of yours, as he never looks away from you. " P...Promise not to scream?" he asked, as he tenses up. You nod your head. " I promise." you reply, as he stands up, and takes his hood of, and you can see he has brown hair which was messy. " Alright go ahead." he says, as he watches you slowly take his mask, and move it away from his face. He quickly looks away. " Jack don't hide from me." you tell him, as you move his face back to look at you. You see his eyes are indeed missing, as black blood oozes out of his eye sockets, and down his face. It looks like he's crying. " I can sense you're scared of me...You want to scream..." he said a little annoyed; but then gasped, as you leaned forwards and kissed him.

He stays still for a few minutes, and then kisses you back, as he pulls you closer to him. You two break for air, as you smile at him. " Just the opposite of screaming..." you said, as EJ picks you up, and carries you to the bed. " I want to take my prize now." he said, as you cover your other kidney, and he chuckles. " No not that prize, a more special prize." he says, as he lays on top of you, and kisses you once more.