Rubellite | Review and Editing Shop | HIATUS

❄ ID | Carol❄

Reviewed by: CarolKnox2

Book Title: ID

Author's Name: Uditasree

CHAPTER ONE

Strengths

1. Character Development:

- The characters are presented with distinct personalities; Revati is portrayed as a dedicated homemaker, while Ishi is depicted as ambitious yet apprehensive about change. This duality creates a relatable dynamic for readers.

2. Dialogue:

- The dialogue between Revati and Balaram showcases their relationship's warmth and familiarity, enriching the narrative. It also highlights cultural nuances in their interactions, making the setting more authentic.

3. Setting:

- The depiction of Hyderabad in the morning, combined with sensory details like the aroma of food, immerses readers in the scene. This vivid description enhances emotional engagement with the characters' experiences.

4. Themes:

- Themes of familial bonds, change, and personal aspiration are evident. Ishi's struggle with moving to a new city reflects broader themes of transition and growth, resonating with many readers.

Room for Improvement

1. Pacing:

- While the chapter contains engaging moments, some sections feel slightly rushed, particularly Ishi's reflections on her life changes. Slowing down to explore her emotions could deepen reader connection.

2. Conflict Development:

- The internal conflict Ishi faces regarding her move is hinted at but not fully explored. Providing more insight into her fears and desires would enhance tension and intrigue.

3. Clarity in Character Relationships:

- While familial dynamics are established, further clarification on Ishi's relationship with Dhruv could enrich understanding of her motivations and emotional landscape.

4. Narrative Voice:

- The narrative voice is generally warm and inviting; however, it could benefit from a more varied tone to reflect different emotional states throughout the chapter. This would add depth to character experiences.

CHAPTER 2: BUTTON IDLY

Strengths

1. Vivid Descriptions:

- The narrative is rich with descriptive language, painting a clear picture of the setting and characters. For example, "The clock struck 6. The skies started to darken from the radiating orange to a canvas that highlights the stars."

2. Character Development:

- The chapter does a great job of developing Ishi and Dhruv, showcasing their relationship and individual personalities. Their playful banter and supportive dynamic are well-executed.

3. Emotional Depth:

- The emotional weight of Ishi's worries about moving to a new city and leaving her family is palpable. The interactions with her father, Balaram, add a touching layer to the story.

4. Cultural References:

- The inclusion of cultural elements, such as the preparation of traditional dishes and wedding rituals, adds authenticity and depth to the story. The glossary at the end is helpful for readers unfamiliar with these terms.