Scott's POV:
The band was at me and mitch's house for this weeks meeting. Mitch, Kirstie, and I was on the couch, Kevin was on the recliner, and Avi was on the loveseat. The meeting went really late, like when we were done it was 10:00p.m. and no one felt like driving so they all stayed.
"Ok guys who wants to play truth or dare," Mitch said making his way to liquor cabinet and pulled out one of many bottles of whiskey we had.
"Sure, we have nothing else to do," I said looking at everyone's agreeing faces. After Mitch poured all the shots the game was under way.
"Kirstie. Truth or Dare?" Avi asked Kirstie. All eyes were on Kirstie.
"Truth." She said confidently.
"Ok... Who was your first?" When Avi asked that question Kirstie's and My eyes widened but no one noticed me they were all focused on Kirstie.
"Uh... um i'm uncomfortable" Kirstie said rubbing the back of her neck.
"Kit just answer the question. Oh let's make it a group truth" Mitch said.
"I'll go first, My first was one of Esther's friends, I remember she was hot" Avi said. Next was Kevin.
"My first, god this is embarrassing, My first was the preacher's daughter and it happened in church." Kevin said hiding behind a pillow.
"O.M.G. Kevin had sex in church. Mister all- american christian boy had sex in church." I said shaking my head.
"My turn, wait should i do boy or girl?" Mitch asked.
"BOTH" We all screamed.
"Ok! My first girl was *cough*Lindsay Hoying*cough*"Mitch tried to hide it.
"Who did you just say?" I asked him Avi got up and put his hands on my shoulders and Mitch got up like for a running start. "Mitch who did you say?" I asked again temidly.
"I said Lindsay Hoying" with that he took off upstairs, slamming his door shut.
"YOU HAD SEX WITH MY SISTER"I screamed trying to go after him but Avi and Kevin had me pinned down. After I calmed down they let go and Mitch came back, but kept his distance of 'course.
"Now the boy, not sure i should say it though." Mitch said worried
"Just say it" Kevin said
"Ok. My first boy was *cough* Joshua Kaplan*cough*"Mitch tried to avoid it again. Now it was Avi's turn to get pinned down.
"Say that again Mitchell" Avi said now Pissed. I grabbed him and signaled to Mitch to continue.
"My first boy was Joshua Kaplan" Mitch said, but he didn't move because he knew i had Avi.
"How he's not even gay?!" Avi asked he was shaking with anger.
"You sure 'cause he fuck me like he was" Now Mitch was just pushing it trying tho see how mad he could make Avi.
"Mitchell Coby Michael Grassi if you don't stop lying i'll hurt you" Kirstie, who's still trying to comprehend things, spoke up.
"What do you mean? He's lying?" Avi asked. Kirstie nodded in response.
"Mitch I know personally that your first was Zayn Malik, the quarterback in high school, I remember 'cause it was under the bleachers during a game.
God why did Scott send me to find you two" Kirstie pinched the bridge of her nose.
"So you didn't have sex with my brother then?" Avi asked,a smile crept on his.
"No that definitely happened" I said,"I heard it." Avi's smile quickly faded into a super frown.
"I guess it's my turn," I said letting go of Avi, "My first is actually in this room."
"I knew you and Mitch fucked, common Avi pay up $50 please" Kevin said and Avi pulled out his wallet but i stopped him.
"No! It's not Mitch. It's Kit" I said Everyone's mouth hung open.
"WHAT?!?" Mitch yelled.
"How? When? Where? More importantly where was I?" Mitch babbled on and on until Kirstie covered his mouth with her hand.
"Alright answer time," I said rubbing my hands together.
"First, when. It was in my senior year her and mitch's Junior year. Now, where... um it happened at the prom actually. And now, why.... Well look at her she's fucking sexy, so curvaceous."I said licking my lips her direction.
"W-would you do it again?" Avi asked.
"Would I do it again? Hell yeah, it was fucking amazing and not just because it was my first." I said.
After that, Mitch was relatively quiet, Avi, Kevin, and I talked about sex and Kirstie, and Kirstie sat there rubbing my shoulders and smiling.
The End.
