Chapter 18- Pony

12.6K 529 532
                                    

Sorry for the wait!

Eren hummed a tune to a song that he had stuck in his head all day, sitting next to Levi as they flipped through the channels at Levi's apartment, 

"Oi, what's that song? I feel like I've heard it before." inquired Levi who was back to his normal self and forgot about what happened a few days ago at the supermarket. 

A light tint of pink covered both of Eren's cheeks before responding "Oh its nothing, I just came up with it." 

Levi rolled his eyes, obviously not buying his excuse of an answer. "What is it?" commanded Levi.

"Its Pony, by ginuwine." He said, praying to god that Levi didn't know that song. But those four words that came out of Levi's mouth made his heart stop. 

"Sing it for me." 

"W-What?" Eren stumbled on his words. 

"What are you deaf? I said sing it for me." Levi said impatiently. 

"I-I don't sing." Eren lied. He's been singing ever since he was a little. But never in front of anyone. 

Levi rolled his eyes for the second time, "Sing." 

Eren sighed, there was no way around this. No matter how much he didn't want to. He knew Levi would make him. Eren was persistent, but Levi was even more persistent than him. 

After a few moments of silent, Eren opened  his mouth

"I'm just a bachelor." Eren's shaky voice sang out "Looking for a partner." 

"Someone who knows how to ride." Eren's face flushed in embarrassment. "Without even falling off."

"Gotta be compatible. Takes me to my limits." Eren continued "Boy when I break you off." He sang, changing the 'girl' in the song to 'boy' 

"I promise that you won't want to get off." he sang, the shakiness slowly fading away 

"If you're horny, let's do it. Ride it, my pony. My saddle's waiting. Come and jump on it." Eren's face by now was a deep red color as he let the oh so familiar lyrics out of his mouth.

"if y-" Eren was cut off by a laugh. And it wasn't his laugh. His eyes widened once he heard the beautiful melody fill up the air. 

Levi was laughing. 

Eren smiled as he heard his laugh. And it was a genuine laugh. Levi even let out a snort in between his laughs, which surprised Eren. Of course, in a good way. Levi couldn't take it, he was hunched over, letting cute little laughs escape his mouth as tears ran down his face.

"So cute." Eren thought, but it also came out of his mouth

Levi wiped his tears away from his face, a smile plastered on his appearance as he calmed down from laughing so much. But the smile soon faded away "I'm not cute, I'm manly." Levi said in a defensive voice. 

"Sure, whatever makes you happy." Eren grinned. "I should be getting home." He said looking at the time on his phone. "Its getting late." 

Levi refrained himself from groaning in frustration. All he did was want to cuddle with his boyfriend all day. Even though he didn't show his affection much, he sure felt it. 

"Bye cutie." Eren said pecking his lips and darting out the door.

-

Eren felt as if he was on cloud 9. Ever since he's been with Levi, he couldn't be any happier. And his parents and friends noticed it too. Even when Jean would try to pick fights with Eren, Eren would just ignore him and go on with his day leaving a confused, wanting to fight and annoyed Jean behind 

Mikasa and Armin were suspicious about how happy Eren has been. But they were just glad he's not down in the dumps anymore. Not only was his attitude up, but so was his grades. He had A's and a few B's. Levi helped him study after school, giving them more time to spend together. Everyone was as happy as can be. 

But happiness doesn't last forever.

 I was listening to Pony by Ginuwine and this popped into my head. I just had to. AND I was thinking of changing the title to "A choice with no regrets." What do you guys think? Anyways, I hope you guys like it. And thanks so much for the 5.6k reads!!! Ily guys so much! Next chapter will be up next week!

Say you love me (Eren x Levi)Where stories live. Discover now