"We can't have three dead bodies now?!" Maddie says to me. Does she not understand she got us into the place in the first place!!
"Calm down.. I don't think Juliet would kill Gabi!" Right as I said that, I tried to quickly reassure myself of that answer. But I just couldn't...
-present day-
"Why couldn't you reassure yourself of that?" The police officer ask me.
"These text sometimes... she would text me.."
"Can I see them?" Of course not but I knew it would look like I'm lying so I have to show them!
I pulled out my phone as I felt all eyes were on me, inside and outside of the room. I go to my camera roll and the first thing he ask me is why I'm going there. I tell him that I have a whole folder showing more proof on why she hates Gabi. He then ask me why I can't just scroll up to our text and I tell him "We deleted all of our conversation so you guys won't be able to find them." After I said his face when blank, and then striaght away took away my phone. He looked at the hundreds of the screenshots and pointed out this one:
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
"Did Gabi have a probelm with keeping secrets?" He finally ask me. I just nod my head yes.
"It feels like she secretly hated her... there was this one time, Maddie, Juliet and I were all playing truth or dare. Maddie asked Juliet truth or Dare and she picked truth. We all decided jokingly to ask her, 'if you had to kill one of us out of the five, to save the other four (including yourself) who would you kill.' Thinking her answer was gonna be Kelsey, because I knew and she knew why Maddie hated her. Her answer was Gabi. It's not like she had to think about it... She straight up said it with a blank expression.." He then looks at me and takes my phone and puts it in a bag.
"Hey!! You can't do that!" I then see him take the phone out of the bag and hand it to me.
"Looks like you know your rights." Followed by a quick wink.
-back to the past-
Maddie and I are sitting in the living room waiting for them to get back with the supplies. Until we heard the doorknob start shaking.
She bolts up "Who called the police??" She whispers to me. But she quickly answered her own question by going into the room and open the closet door. "Where is your fucking cell phone you bitch??!" She drags her out of the closet and starts getting on top of her and beating her until near death.
"MADDIE STOP!! HER PHONE IS IN MY POCKET!" Silenced is quickly followed, but then interrupted when it is followed by Kelsey's crying.
"Man up you cunt!" There goes Kelsey back into the locked closet.
"GUYSSS!! IT'S ME J OPEN THE FUCKING DOOR SHE IS SOO HEAVY!!"
We rush to the door, and then we open it.
"Did you kill her??" Maddie says with a glimmer of hope in her voice. I have a felling that if Juliet didn't do it then sure as hell Maddie would do it.
Juliet finally answers after a solid 5 minutes of silence..
