(This is only out of four of them im sorry..)
Aries: jeff the killer
Taurus: ben drowned
Gemini: jeff the killer
Cancer: laughing jack
Leo: the bloody painter
Virgo: ben drowned
Libra: laughing jack
Scorpio: the bloody painter
Sagittarius: jeff the killer
Capricorn: all four
Aquarius: ben drowned
Pisces: the bloody painter