Beautiful || Genderbent Heathers X Reader

Chapter 6

You feel a tap on your shoulder as you slowly awake to the sound of the disc player functioning. You must've fallen asleep somewhere during Cinderella. Probably after the climax of the movie....Eh. You've already watched it a lot.

Your eyes flutter as Duke looks over to you."You're lucky we didn't do anything stupid while you were asleep." He says, flicking you on the shoulder. You flinch, laughing slightly.

"Okay, okay...what did you guys put in the disc player?" You ask as the movie starts.

"It was some Disney movie called Frozen. It looked interesting, so we put it in." Chandler says, placing something on your head. You quickly take it off before it falls, smiling.

"Thanks." You say, taking a handful out of the bowl of freshly popped popcorn.

"You're welcome, since you didn't get any during Cinderella." He says, snuggling into his blanket on the couch.

The movie begins to play as you feel weight fall on your left shoulder. You look over to see McNamara sleeping soundly on your shoulder. You smile to yourself, intensely fangirling on the inside.

Oh my gosh- he looks so cute and peaceful! You internally shriek while attempting to calm yourself down. You take a deep breath, taking a fistful of popcorn and shoving it into your mouth.

"Woah, it looks so real..." Victor says, basically rendering him speechless in awe over the art style. You hum to the opening song, a smile on your face.

[Reactions Montage]

Hans appears on-screen, as you can feel McNamara leaning away from you. He rams into the coffee table, not even waking up. You flinch at the loud noise.

"Who the f is you?" Duke asks, putting his hand up to the screen to point at him.

-------->

Anna just said yes to marry Hans.

"You met him what, 20 minutes ago?!? He could be a fucking murderer for all you know!" Chandler yells, facepalming.

-------->

Hans just abandoned Anna in the room as you cover your ears. All three Hunters and Victor are screaming at the TV. You let out a small laugh to yourself.

-------->
Hans raised the sword behind Elsa, about to cut her.

"C'mon, turn around...ELSA YOU CAN'T DIE ON ME!" McNamara yells, pointing at the TV accusingly.

--------->
Anna freezes over completely as Elsa clings to her.

"Noooooooo!" You and McNamara say simultaneously. A tear slips down your cheek as you sniffle. This part always got to you...

--------->

Hans and the Duke just got locked up and sent back to Weaselton.

"Serves the bitch right..." Victor yells, flipping him off.

-------->

"Awww, otp." You say at the end of the movie, seeing Anna and Kristoff kiss. You smile happily as the credits begin to roll.

You turn the TV off, sighing and folding up the blanket that you used. You place the blanket on the back of the couch, looking over to the clock. Jesus fuck it's only 11pm?!?

"Hey guys, wanna play truth or dare?" Victor asks as you nod happily, along with the Hunters.

"I'll start!" Duke says, moving over to make room for Victor and Chandler on the floor. They all sit in a circle as your phone rings.

Oh my gosh, it's Aliyah! She's probably wondering where the hell you are!

"I gotta take this." You say, pointing to your phone. You walk away from the game, going through a few rooms and taking a seat on the staircase. You slide to answer the phone.

"Y/N, where are you? Everyone's been looking everywhere for you, there's even a shrine set up at school!" She sobs over the phone. Hearing her cry causes a few tears to slip down your cheeks. You wanted to be there to comfort her and tell her it's all going to be okay...but you can't.

"Aliyah, you're going to laugh at me and say I'm insane, but bear with me here. I sorta kind got sent to 1989..." You say as you hear her shriek over the phone.

"Oh my gosh, does that mean-" She starts as you laugh.

"Yes, I'm in the Heathers universe. But, everyone's now gender swapped..." You say as her shrieks grow louder. She starts fangirlijg over the phone, laughing and asking you tons of questions. You go to messages and send her a selfie of all of you guys together. She looks at it, squealing and rambling to herself.

"You can tell me all about it when you come back. You are going to come back... Aren't you?" She asks, your heart shattering on impact. You sniffle a bit, choking back a sob.

"I-I don't know if I'm ever going to come back..." You stutter as she gasps.

"R-really? Are you stuck?" She asks as you lean over onto the side of the railings.

"Yeah, I don't know how to get back...but I'm determined it'll all work itself out in the end." You say, taking a deep breath to calm you and her down. You can hear Aliyah also take a deep breath.

"Talk to you tomorrow, okay?" She says to you, a happy mood already set in both of your minds. You had to see her again, you had to.

"Okay, I love you bestie!" You say to her as she replies'love you too!' You hang up the phone, laying a hand over your forehead and leaning into your knees. This new life was harder than you thought...

You get up, taking a final deep breath to settle your emotions then walking down the stairs. You turn the corner, Victor and the Hunters looking at you.

"What were you two talking about? Going back to where?" Victor asks, leaning up against the wall with his arms crossed.

"None of your business, Victor. Stop being so damn nosy, all of you." You say to them, a sigh escaping your lips.

"What do you mean that you're stuck here?" Chandler asks you, walking up to you and trying to intensity the height difference.

"Nothing." You say to him, grabbing his collar and pulling him to your height.

"Just forget about it." You whisper to him, sending shivers down his spine. He gulps as you let him go, smirking. You give him a hip bump, making your way back into the living room.

The room begins to spin around you and you try to steady yourself on the couch. Your eyelids grow heavy as Aliyah's voice plays through your head.

"Nice job, you've created 5 time paradoxes. You didn't think there wouldn't be any repercussions...did you?"

You feel yourself collapse onto the couch, falling into a deep sleep.