Spider-Man: Darkest Hour (Spider-Man/Fem Creepypastas Crossover)

Chapter XVI: A Night To Remember

Slenda's Mansion
November 6th ??

Benny's P.O.V

Welp....todays the day! Harry wanted peter to hang out with him and miles today and I was sitting next to peter and the girls eating breakfast....most of the girls were staring at us...most were smirking while Jane as glaring at me....whats her problem?

"So...had fun last night?" Jill asked me while smirking causing me to look away while Peter hid his face.

"No! W-we were just playing video games! Nothing special really!" Peter peter lied while blushing.

"Yeah! It's not like we're together or anything!..." I lied aswell, causing everyone to look towards us with narrowed eyes.

"Really? That's not what you guys said earlier..." Jackie said pointing her fork at us both.

"You heard our conversation?" Peter asked.

"Of course we did! And a lot of...other things last night~" Jill said grinning.

"Oh Peter! Your so big!" Jill mocked me causing me to cover my ears while Peter sunk down into his chair.

"Stop it!" I yelled while the girls just continued laughing at us.

"My my peter.....didn't know you were such an animal~" Jill said staring at Peter intently.

"Back off! He's mine!" I yelled as I pulled him close to me.

"Aww come on Benny....sharing is caring~" jill said as she moved closer to Peter causing him to slowly back away.

"Tempting, but I'll pass..." Peter said causing Jill to huff and sit back down in her chair..

"One day itsy....One day~" Jill said while smirking at peter, I'll tell her one thing, she better stay the hell away from him, he's my bug-boy!

"So....I guess you and him are a thing now?" Jess said as she pointed at the two of us.

"Yeah....I guess..." Peter said while scratching his head and blushing, causing me to blush aswell...As he said this Jane stood up and threw her plate to the sink and stormed off.

"....Looks like somebody didn't like the news...." Jess said as she shrugged and drunk her orange juice.

"I'm gonna go talk to her." Peter said as he was about to stand up before I stopped him.

"I'll do it...." I said as he nodded and sat back down, I then walked towards Jane's room and knocked on her door...i knew she had feelings for him but I slept with him anyways...god I'm a terrible friend!

"Go away!" She said from the other side of the door.

"Look i know you like Peter bu-

"If you knew about my feelings for him then why did you do it?" Jane yelled.

"Because I liked him too Jane! Look can you please let me in so I can explain myself?" I asked. I then heard the door unlock and saw Jane with tears in her eyes....oh great job benny! You slept with her crush!

"What do you want?" Jane said as I walked in and sat on her bed, I then patted the bed for her to sit next to me.

She hesitated at first but eventually sat down, I then took a deep breath and sighed.

"Look I'm sorry for what happened okay? I-i just wanted to tell him how I felt, h-he's a really great guy Jane...he's the only guy I've met who treats me like a normal girl! He even helped me overcome my fear of water! Then last night happened..one thing lead to another..and I just kissed him, I didn't think about my actions last night because I was just desperate....i just wanted him so bad! And I got him but....now I think I lost one of my friends in the process...." I said looking down, I then felt a hand on my shoulder and saw Jane smiling softly.