Not Yours (Peter Pan fan fiction)

Chapter 1: Saved or Captured?

He heard my cries for help, he saved me, helped me run away, took me to a place I thought was safe, then kept me prisoner the moment we landed on this island. He had saved me from a beating from my stepmom and stepsister by killing them both. He then comforted me, telling me everything was ok and that I was safe now. He told me I could go with him to a magical island called Neverland.

We talked for a long time that night before I agreed. He said his name was Peter Pan and he would protect me. As we laughed walking down the abandoned street eating ice cream from a gas station, he flew in front of me.

“So what do you say Skyler? Will you come with me? No grown ups or evil sisters. You’ll have a home and a bed. We can play all day and you can be a mother to the lost boys!” He smiled wildly. “A mother? I’d be a terrible mother. I don’t know the first thing about being one. The only nice memories I have of a mother is my real Mum before she passed away.” I replied holding onto her necklace that I always wore. “You’ll warm up the idea trust me. I see it in you. You’re so kind, caring, and gentle.” He told me as I sat on a bench with my bag of clothes in hand. I looked away.

“Come on Skyler, you never grow up there and you don’t have to deal with this world anymore.” He sat very close to me on the bench, causing me to blush. “How do we get to this Neverland of yours?” I asked wiping the chocolate from the corners of my mouth. “With this!” He pulled out a small bean causing me to give him a funny look. “It's a magic bean that will take us anywhere we want to go. But once we get there you can never leave without my permission. Do you trust me?” He asked scooting closer to me, moving my bag of clothes so he could place a hand on mine.

“ You saved me Peter, of course I trust you.” I replied looking deep into his eyes.

“So that’s a yes then?” He smiled at me. I laughed at his excitement while nodding my head “Yes, I’ll go with you.” I giggled as he jumped up and spun me around as my ice cream fell to the ground.

“Let’s go then! I’m so excited for you to meet my lost boys and you’ll be a lost girl! The very first! Grab your bag Sky, we’re going home.” He told me with kind and excited eyes.

I grabbed my bag as he threw down the magic bean, causing a portal to open up. I stepped back in fear of what was in there. “Don’t be afraid, put your bag on your back, hold onto me tightly, and just think of Neverland.” He told me calmly looking into my eyes. At this moment he had my full trust when that was the moment I should’ve ran away.

We jumped in the portal as I clung to Peter’s arm. I closed my eyes getting dizzy. “Get ready we’re about to land.” Peter warned me, pulling closer to hold onto his waist.

All of a sudden it wasn’t a black hole anymore it was bright, I opened my eyes and looked around at the beautiful beach and the forest behind us. Peter slowly lowered us down. As soon as my feet touched the ground I let go to get a good look at everything. “It’s beautiful Peter! Thank you so much! I owe you big time!” I smiled happily as I tackled him in a hug. “Oh, don’t thank me just yet, love. Come with me.” He told me smiling. Although he seemed different now, his smile was different. “Are we going to the lost boys now Peter?” I asked playing it cool. “Yes, one more thing.” I looked up at him in confusion. “It’s Pan now, don’t call me Peter again.” He told me in a stern voice. I no longer felt safe. “Why’s that?” I asked curiously. “Because I said so.” He snapped at me. I just nodded and stayed quiet for a bit.

Until curiosity got the best of me. “Are you ok? You changed the moment we landed.” I asked. “Perfectly happy now that I have you here now. Your family made it so easy for me to get you to come with me. Now you’re mine. You belong to me now.” He told me. “You said there were no rules that I was free.” I told him frightened as I stopped walking. “I never said you were free, love. Now come.” He ordered. “What are you going to do with me?” I asked trying to keep my distance. “You’ll find out soon enough.” He replied, waiting on me with a hand out. I kept my hands close to me. “Come on Sky, don’t you trust me?” He taunted as I shook my head no. “No? That hurts Sky.” He pretended to be hurt before laughing.

“Now, I know what you’re thinking so don’t run away. I know this whole island and nobody leaves without me knowing about it. I have an attachment to this island so I can feel whenever someone arrives or leaves. Not that you could escape this place anyway.” He laughed taking a step toward me. I instinctively took a step back. “Oh, is that how you wanna play?” He asked. “Come on out boys! We’ve got a fun one on our hands.” He smiled as a bunch of boys came out from the trees and bushes. I went to run in one direction but there was a lost boy there. And then in the opposite the we’re more. I was completely surrounded, being pushed back and forth until one grabbed me.

“If you’re so big then why do you need to trap me with all these boys? Why not just let me run and catch me yourself, Peter?” I tested him. Not the smartest idea I’ve ever had but worth a shot. “Testing me are you? You saw me kill your horrid family and you want to test me? You’re not the brightest I’ll admit. But you’ll do.” He laughed walking towards me. I tried stepping back but the lost boys behind me just pushed me down onto my hands and knees. I saw Peter’s boots and tights in front of me. He came down to my level and harshly snatched my chin up to look at him. “I told you to call me Pan. Never call me Peter without my permission again. Are we clear on that?” He asked. I didn’t reply, I just gave him a mean glare. He then picked me up by my throat. “Answer me! Now are we clear?” He screamed at me. I tried to pry his hand off my throat, with a look of terror in my eyes replacing the glare I once shot at him. “Y-y-yes.” I choked out. “Yes what?” he demanded as he threw me hard onto the ground. “Yes, Pan.” I coughed out. “Good. Now take her to the cage, she can’t be trusted running around freely.” He ordered some boys. I coughed and gasped for air as some boys picked me up and dragged me to a small cage
------------------------------------------------------
Hey guys! Thanks for reading the first chapter of my Peter Pan story!! I wasn't gonna post it until I finished my other stories on here but I wanted to get opinions on it! I have a few more chapters of this on Google Docs so if you like it comment below and vote on this chapter so I can upload more. Thank you so much again for reading ❤💚💜💙💛