Craig's pov
I was chilling with everyone after the whole little sex prank Andy and Bryce did to me. We were all sitting and having a good time. "I still can't believe they did that."
"I can," Panda said laughing.
"Craig, you had to have known they were gonna mess with you," Tyler said.
"I will kill him if needed."
"Craig, calm down," Brian said sitting next to Brock.
"Sorry just... things have happened and I'm overprotective of her."
"That's understandable, but you know Bryce isn't going to hurt her." I was quiet after that statement.
"So what now?" Tyler asked. Everyone shrugged.
"I want pizza," Brock said.
"I'll order it," Brian said.
"Yay!"
"You're such a kid," Brian said smiling at Brock.
"Can't help it."
"Lovebirds," Anthony said. They blushed and flipped him off. "Am I right?" Brian leaves the room to order pizza. "Now, Brock, am I right?" Anthony asked again.
"Anthony, shut up."
"So what's going on with you and Tyler, Craig?" Marcel asked.
"I don't know what you're talking about."
"Really?" Brock said. I stayed quiet.
"Pizza will be here soon," Brian said walking back over to Brock.
"Okay."
"Andy out of her dungeon, yet?"
"Nope."
"Should we tell her pizza is on the way?"
"Yeah."
"Come on," Tyler said getting up. We headed up to Andy's room. Tyler knocked on the door. There was no answer. I went to turn the doorknob, but it was locked. I was confused, so I grabbed the spare key to her room off of the door way. I unlocked the door and Tyler and I walked in. Tyler covered my eyes. I tried moving his hand away. "No. We're just going to leave the room."
"Why?" I asked. He doesn't say anything, just leads me out of the room and shuts the door. "Tyler, what the hell is going on?"
"Craig, it's nothing."
"It's obviously something," I said starting to get annoyed.
"You don't want to know." My jaw clenched and I tensed up. I knew what Tyler was talking about.
"Are you fucking kidding me right now?"
"No." I ripped his hand away from my face. "Craig, you need to calm down."
"How do I calm down? That's my little sister!"
"I get that, but you still need to calm down a bit."
"How, Tyler?" I asked putting my head in my hands.
"Wait till they get up then talk to them."
"Can you be there with me? You know, to make sure I don't murder Bryce."
"Yeah we don't need you in jail."
"I don't even want to go back downstairs."
"Let's go chill in your room then." I nodded and we walked down the hall to my room. "Now what?" I shrugged.
"I was kinda hoping you had an idea."
"Not really."
"Tyler, can I ask you something?"
"Yeah."
"What should I do about Andy and Bryce?"
"I know you're upset but talk to them first don't blow up at them."
"Bryce literally just told me he wouldn't fuck her."
"Maybe she wanted it." I sighed.
"Maybe you're right." He put a hand on my shoulder. I put my hand on top of his. "Thank you, Tyler."
"No problem." Someone knocked on my door.
"Come in." Andy walked in. She had changed into her pajamas.
"Why you in your room?"
"I just needed a minute. Andy, we need to talk."
"What's up?" She sat in one of the love sacs.
"I just have a few questions. Do you like genuinely like Bryce?"
"Yes."
"Did you guys have fun tonight?"
"Yeah." I nodded.
"Are you two together?"
"Yes." I sighed.
"Did you guys use protection tonight?"
She blushed.
"Ye-yes."
"Look I'm not happy with you guys. Bryce lied straight to my face. I mean, I get it but seriously. You could've just told me the truth. Did you want it to happen?"
"Yes...it was my idea."
"Woah okay. I just wanted to be sure. I guess I can't be entirely mad at you guys. Just, please be safe."
"Craig, you know I will...after what happened." I started to tear up.
"I know, Andy," I said quietly.
"What happened?" Tyler asked.
"Craig can tell you, only you, later." He nodded.
"But that's really all. Thank Tyler though. I was gonna kill him," I said.
"Don't tell big brother or someone will be dead." We all laughed.
"Anyway, Brian ordered pizza it should be here soon."
"We'll keep this between us," Tyler said.
"Thanks."
"Oh and Anthony is onto Brian and Brock and, well, us. Because apparently we've all got something going on between each each other."
"Because you're all gay and all the ships are going to happen. Shit, I wouldn't even be mad if Bryce left me for Ohm."
"What the hell, Andy?"
"I don't know...I just like gay shit okay." Tyler and I nodded and laughed.
"Wait, so you're saying that something's gonna happen between us?" Tyler asked, motioning to him and I.
"Please, I know a gay person when I see one. Even if they haven't come out."
"I'm not gay," Tyler and I said in unison.
"Uh huh then why have you already kissed?"
"What?"
"I'm not stupid, Craig."
"We havent-" Tyler put a hand on my shoulder.
"I'm your sister you can't hide this from me." I sighed and Tyler kissed my cheek. "So cute."
"Andy, stop," I said blushing.
"Nope."
"You're gonna be the death of me."
"Well, your funeral's already planned."
"Damn."
"Love you."
"Love you too, asshole."
"Bitch."
"Cunt."
"Assbutt."
"The fuck?" Tyler said.
"Fucker."
"Mannequin hoe."
"Flappy pussy."
"You're a barrel." I rolled my eyes.
"Andy, can us stay between us?" Tyler asked motioning to him and I.
"Duh. Who do you think I am? Nogla?" He laughed quietly and kissed my cheek. Bryce walked in.
"Um pizza's here."
"Thanks, Bryce. And don't lie to me if you want to fuck my sister. Just be honest next time." He blushed and awkwardly laughed.
"So pizza?" Tyler asked.
"Yeah." We all walked downstairs to grab some pizza.
"Food!" Andy stole a whole box and ran to the living room. I grabbed a box for Tyler and I and Bryce grabbed a few slices.
"Andy took my pizza," Anthony said with a sad face.
"Andy, give Anthony his pizza!"
"Fine." She gave Anthony an empty plate.
"There's nothing there!"
"Heh sorry."
"You're such a dick!"
"I was hungry!"
"You have your own!"
"Sorry..." Andy took her pizza and went upstairs. Bryce followed after her.
"She knows I'm just messing with her, right?"
"She does, but doesn't."
"What's that supposed to mean?"
"She knows you're joking but it still upsets her."
"I'm sorry."
"It's not your fault why she's like that."
"I know but I still feel bad."
"She'll tell you not to."
"Sounds about right." Bryce came back downstairs with a quiet Andy. "Andy," Anthony said.
"Hmm?"
"I was just messing around."
"I know."
"Okay good. I didn't want you thinking I was serious."
"Felt like you were though..." she said quietly.
"What? No. I had plenty of pizza before you came down. I was just trying to have some fun."
"Sorry..."
"Don't say you're sorry. I'm sorry I made you feel that way."
"Not your fault."
"I'm still sorry, Andy. Golf it tomorrow?"
"Sure."
"Awesome." Andy smiled slightly. "It'll be me, you, Bryce, Brian, and Craig."
"Brian, you mess with me during golf it and I'll kill you," Andy said glaring at him. Brian put his hands up.
"I'm after Jiggly."
"Just remember I have everyone's funeral planned in this house including mine." We all looked at her weird. "I love you guys, but don't fucking test me." She smiled and left the room.
"Do you have a death wish?" Tyler asked Bryce.
"No why?"
"She's scary," Anthony said laughing.
"But cute."
"Aww," Brian and Brock said.
"I'm not cute. I'm emo," Andy said walking back in the kitchen standing next to Bryce.
"We're not having this discussion again, Andy," Bryce said poking her. She took his hand and looked like she licked it. "Ew why'd you lick me?"
"I didn't lick you. I poked you with my tongue."
"Gross."
"You'll live." He chuckled.
"Andy, why are you like this?" She shrugged.
"Sounds about right," Brian said. She flipped Brian off. We all laughed.
"I'm tired. I'm going to bed."
"Night, Andy," I said. She nodded and headed upstairs.
"Mario kart?" Brian whispered to Brock. He nodded. They ran upstairs and Bryce walked up there.
"Well okay then." Everyone had started going to bed and soon it was just Tyler and I.
"So."
"So?"
"I don't know."
"What do you want to talk about?" I asked as I started cleaning up.
"Don't know."
"That helps," I said.
"I know."
"I can't believe Andy knows."
"She finds out everything."
"You're right. Tyler, can I ask you something?"
"Yeah."
"Do you think maybe Mario kart is something else for Brian and Brock?"
"Oh totally."
"Cuz they "play" a lot."
"Yep." I looked over at Tyler and smiled to myself.
"What you smiling at?"
"How cute you are." He blushed.
"Mini, I'm not cute."
"But you are."
"Craig, seriously."
"Fine be that way."
"Don't get all pissy with me," Tyler said walking over to me. I roll my eyes. "Don't roll your eyes at me," he said grabbing my waist.
"What're you going to do about it?" He smirked.
"Nothing down here." I blushed. "Should we head upstairs?" Tyler asked rubbing my arm.
"Yeah." He grabbed my hand and we walked upstairs. I felt nervous. We walked in my room and he shut the door. "What time is it?"
"It's 12, Craig."
"Dang." He nodded. I yawned. He came over and wrapped his arms around me.
"Tired, cutie?"
"Yeah."
"Why don't we lay down for the night?"
"Agreed." Tyler took his shirt off and then laid down. I changed and laid down beside him. He snuggled into me and kissed my cheek. I smiled. He lightly kissed my chest as he fell asleep. I feel asleep after. I woke up to something tickling my chin.
"Wh-what?" I felt small kisses being planted across my chest.
"Morning, Tyler."
"Good morning, Craig," he said kissing up to my jaw.
"When did you wake up?"
"A few minutes ago." I nodded and rubbed my eyes. He was wrapped around me. I looked at the time. It was 10:00 am. "Craig."
"Hmm?"
"You're really warm." I laughed. He nuzzled into my chest. The door opened and Andy walked in.
"Here. I got y'all biscuitville."
"I got so scared. Thanks, Andy," Tyler said sitting up. Andy laughed.
"Yeah I don't normally knock to walk in to Craig's room....might have to start."
"Why?" Tyler asked with a mouthful.
"Well, I mean unless you want me to walk in while you guys are having sex then I should start knocking."
"Jesus Christ, Andy."
"What?"
"We haven't done anything like that yet."
"Exactly yet. Key word." I watched Tyler hide his face as he blushed.
"Love you guys." She walked out of my room.
"Love you too," we said.
"She..I don't even know." Tyler shrugged and got up. He went into the bathroom and started brushing his teeth. I started eating my food. He walked back into the room and sat in front of me. I made a funny face. He giggled. I finished eating and started getting ready.
"Craig?"
"Hmm?"
"How long do you think we'll be a secret?"
"I feel like not that along around our friends." He laughed a little.
"Yeah. They'll probably start clueing in soon."
"That's fine. We know they won't say anything."
"Yeah I trust them. I'm just not sure if I'm ready to tell the world."
"We don't have to yet." He nodded. I smiled slightly.
"Thank you."
"No problem." He got up and hugged me. I hugged him back. He kissed me and grabbed his shirt from last night, throwing it on. "Let's go." He nodded and we walked downstairs.
"Look who finally got up," Nogla said.
"We didn't sleep that late," I said.
"You're that last ones up."
"It's still not that late."
"Don't care."
"Someone hasn't gotten enough dick," Tyler said walking into the kitchen.
Andy started laughing.
"I'm not gay," Nogla said.
"Yeah that's why Lui left your room really early this morning," Andy said smirking. Everyone's attention turned to Nogla.
"Wh-what? Pfft no."
"Don't lie, Nogla. You liked it," Lui said walking downstairs. Nogla hid his face. We all started laughing.
"Man, this is fun."
"About as much fun as you and Tyler had," Brian said.
"We didn't do shit."
"Yeahhhhhh."
"They really didn't. Otherwise, it would have been very terrifying to walk in the room," Andy said.
"Wait, you two slept in Craig's room? Like together?" Brock asked.
"We were talking and fell asleep."
"Quite suspicious," Brian joked. I flipped him off. "No not me. Do that to Tyler." I rolled my eyes. Everyone laughed, including Tyler.
"Alright that's enough."
"You good?" Tyler asked. I was quiet. I knew Andy knew I was annoyed. He nodded and walked to the fridge. I got up and headed outside. Andy came out shortly after.
"Annoyed?"
"Yeah."
"Do I need to say something?"
"No, Andy."
"Alright."
"We're trying to think of a time and way to tell everyone."
"Yeah."
"I just wish they'd stop.teasing about it, because I don't want Tyler to be nervous."
"I know. Maybe we can get them to focus on Brian and Brock till you guys are ready?"
"Does Mario kart mean something for them? Like other than actually playing."
"You really think Brock plays Mario kart in his spare time? He doesn't like the game."
"So, like, is that code for smashing or something?"
"Duh. They're not exactly quiet."
"Sorry I'm too focused on Tyler to pay attention."
"That's cute." I started blushing.
"Andy, stop."
"Hehe nope." I shook my head.
"He's just so adorable."
"You guys are really cute together."
"Thanks, Andy," I said blushing.
"No problem, Bro."
"You and Bryce are adorable too. Sorry I've been so yikes about it."
"It's fine."
"You're my little sister. It's just harder for me to accept these things."
"Yeah." I hugged her. She hugged me back.
"We should probably get back inside."
"Yeah." We walked back inside and all eyes were on Andy and I.
"What?" we asked in sync. Everyone just shook their heads. "Well okay."
"What now?" I asked.
"Death?" Andy asked casually.
"No," Bryce said before I could say anything.
"God danngit." He gave her a 'really' look. "I'm a fucked up person."
"We know, but we love you."
"Thanks." We laughed. "I'm bored."
"Same."
"Hmm. Let's play Mario Party."
"Our version or Brock and Brian's?" I whispered to Alex.
"I said Party not kart so our version," she whispered back. I laughed. She laughed while everyone looked at us.
"Whatcha laughing at?" Brian asked.
"None of your mother fucking business."
"Damn someone's touchy."
"Shut the fuck up."
"Jesus Christ."
"Gerard Way is not here so chill." Everyone laughed.
"God you're such an emo."
"I prefer the term yeemo." We looked at her confused.
"Family 👏🏻 friendly 👏🏻 alternative 👏🏻 content👏🏻."
"Damn, you're definitely Craig's sister." She smiled. I mimicked Andy and then laughed. She flipped me off.
"I love you too."
"Now let's get started." We all sat down and grabbed controllers. So far we were all tied. After hours of playing and screaming, Andy finally won.
"Fuck yeah! I win!" We all laughed. "I want food."
"Well what do you want?" Bryce asked.
"Hmm I don't know."
"Should I order Bojangles?"
"Yes." Bryce stepped outside to order the Bojangles while we all sat around the living room. Andy put her legs on me.
"Why, Andy?" I asked laughing.
"Because I can." I shook my head.
"Love you, Bro."
"Love you too." Bryce walked back in.
"It will be here soon." Andy nodded and we put on scary movies. We were all so focused on the movie that we didn't hear the doorbell ring. There was a loud knock.
"FOOD!" Andy got up and ran to the door. We laughed and she came back with all of our food. "Who's hungry?"
"Me!" Everyone shouted. Andy laughed and handed us our food. We all started eating as we resumed Hocus Pocus. We were all so quiet you'd think we were dead. I snuggled with Tyler as we were reaching the end of the movie. Andy fell asleep so Bryce carried her upstairs. Brian and Brock left to fuck. Everyone else slowly went to bed.
"What now cute thang?"
"I don't know."
"Do you wanna go lay down?"
"I guess. I'm not really tired though."
"Well we could just talk."
"About what?" I shrugged.
"I have no idea."
"That helps." I stuck my tongue out at him. He raised an eyebrow.
"What."
"Nothing you're just cute." He blushed. "Heh." I went over to him and wrapped my arms around his waist. He smiled. I kissed him passionately and pulled him against me. He kissed back.
"Holy shit balls," Brian said walking downstairs. We pulled away from each other. "So are you two a thing?"
"Uhhh."
"Let's talk about you and Brock first," Tyler said smirking. Brian blushed. "Is there something between you guys?"
"Maybe there is maybe there isn't."
"Brian, come on. I know there's something."
"Ugh fine. Yes don't tell anyone."
"So Mario kart huh?" Tyler said waggling his eyebrows.
"Stop."
"Honestly, clever." He laughed.
"We'll keep your secret as long as you keep ours."
"Deal." Tyler grabbed my hand and leaned on my shoulder. I smiled. "Well, you two love birds have fun," Brian said walking upstairs.
"Shall we continue?" Tyler blushed and nodded. I kissed him again. He kissed back wrapping his arms around my neck. I wrapped my arms around his waist. He played with my hair as our lips moved in sync. I smiled into the kiss.
"Craig."
"Hmm?"
"I love you," he mumbled into the kiss.
"I love you too." He started kissing on my neck lightly. I shivered a bit.
"We should get upstairs before someone else catches us."
"Yeah we should." Tyler took my hand and led me to my room. "Heh might be good to lock the door." His eyes widened. "Do you want to deal with Andy randomly walking in?" He shook his head. "Exactly." I locked the door and Tyler looked nervous. "You okay?"
"J-just a little n-nervous."
"Me too." He walked over to me and grabbed my hand.
"We don't have to do anything like that if you're not ready for it."
"I want to."
"Are you sure?" He nodded. I smiled and kissed him. He kissed back. I wrapped my arms around him. He tangled his fingers in my hair. I laid back on the bed pulling him with me. He straddled my waist and trailed kisses down my neck. I moaned softly. He rubbed his hands up and down my chest. I smiled at him.
"Craig."
"Hmm?"
"You're so handsome."
"So are you." He blushed and hid his face in my neck. I laughed.
"Don't laugh at me."
"Too late." He whined and started sucking on my neck. I moaned.
"Craig," he whimpered.
"Yes?"
"Fuck me?"
"Heh yes." He kissed me roughly, tugging at my shirt. I pulled back and took it off kissing him again. He kissed across my chest. I tugged on his shirt. He sat up straight and pulled it off throwing it to the side. I pulled him back into a kiss. He moaned into the kiss. I flipped us over and started to kiss his neck. He moaned softly. I smirked.
"What're you smirking at?"
"You sound cute." He blushed again and put his hands over his face. I moved his hands away. His cheeks were a deep crimson. "You're cute."
"Stoopp."
"Nooo." He whined.
"I've never seen this side of you Tyler."
"What do you mean?" he asked innocently.
"You being all embarrassed." He blushed once again. I smiled.
"I can't help it."
"I think it's cute."
"Craig," he squeaked. I laughed again. He pouted.
"Don't pout."
"Sorry."
"Don't need to apologize."
"Sor- okay." I laugh. "Craig."
"What?"
"Kiss me?" I kissed him and he kissed me back, pulling me closer to him.
I smiled into the kiss as I started to kiss down his neck. He moaned softly.
I started to leave hickeys. His breathing became shaky. I trailed kisses down his chest. "Craig please."
"Please what?"
"Hurry up," he begged. I smirked as I took his pants off. He gasped and then smiled. I laughed as I took my pants off and kissed him. He kissed me back wrapping his arms around my neck.
"I love you."
"I love you too." He tugged at my hair and the band of my boxers. I took them off. He gulped.
"Do you want to stop?" He shook his head quickly and went back to kissing me. I kissed him back and he flipped us back over. He kissed down my chest, leaving hickeys as he went. I moaned softly. He slowly dragged his fingers down my side. I shivered a bit. He took his boxers off and started kissing my neck. I moaned a little louder. He flipped us over once more.
"We're going to have to be quiet."
"I'll try my best."
"Heh." He cupped my cheeks and pulled me to him for a kiss. I kissed back.
"Craig, please." I slowly slid into him. He moaned. I started moving at an even pace. "Craig," he moaned.
"Hmm?"
"F-faster." I smiled and sped up. His moans got louder. I smirked. He gripped onto my biceps and bit his lip.
I groaned. "Fuck." I started to kiss his neck again. "Craig," he moaned.
"Don't be too loud." He nodded and bit his lip. I kissed him, our lips moving in sync. I sped up more.
"Oh fuck!"
"Tyler." He groaned and I moaned.
"Craig," he moaned. "I'm cl-close."
"Me too." His moans got louder as he got closer to finishing.
"Craig!"
"Tyler!" We finished and I pulled out of him and laid beside him.
"F-fuck that felt good."
"Yeah." He snuggled into me. I smiled.
"I love you, Craig."
"I love you too, Tyler." His breathing slowed as he fell asleep. I fell asleep shortly after him.
Andy's pov
Bryce kissed my cheek before laying in bed. "I love you."
"I love you too."
"I'm bored," I said rolling over to face him.
"Well what do you want to do, beautiful?" he asked rubbing my side.
"I don't know." He planted a small kiss on my lips. I smiled.
"I love you so much, Andy."
"I love you too, Bryce." He kissed my cheek. I poked his nose. He scrunched his nose. I giggled. "You're still a cunt muffin."
"Oh so you wanna play that game, huh?"
"What game?"
"Do you remember what happened the last time you called me a cunt muffin?"
"Can't say I recall."
"Hmm maybe I need to refresh your memory."
"Maybe you do cunt muffin." He shook his head and rolled on top of me. "Well hello."
"Hi," he said smirking.
"So are you going to do anything about it or what?" He slid his hands up my shirt.
"You bet your ass I am."
"I don't think you will." He pulled my shirt off and kissed down my neck. I moaned softly. I pulled away and took my shirt off.
"You're so beautiful."
"And you're handsome." He blushed and pecked my lips. "You're cute when you blush."
"Andy, stop."
"Nah." He rolled his eyes and ran his fingers down my side. "Don't roll your eyes at me." He rolled his eyes again.
"How rude." He smirked and bit his lip. "That's hot." He blushed.
"You're hot."
"No I'm not."
"Yes you are."
"No." He sighed. I frowned.
"I love you, Andy."
"I love you too, Bryce," I mumbled.
"Baby, what's wrong?"
"Nothing."
"Baby."
"What?"
"What's going on?"
"What do you mean?"
"I was trying to compliment you and you just seemed...I don't know."
"Like I said before I got bullied for how I look so I'm not the most confident person. I still get made fun of for how I look."
"Like I said, they don't matter. You are so beautiful and you're perfect." I smiled slightly. He kissed my nose and laid beside me. I poked his stomach. "Why?"
"I don't know it looked pokeable." He laughed. "Could we continue?"
"Continue what, beautiful?"
"You know what." He slid his hand down my side and into my underwear. He kissed my neck and rubbed me gently. I moaned softly. He slid three fingers inside of me and kissed me. I kissed back. He pulled his fingers out and pulled me on top of him. I started to kiss his neck. He took a deep breath. I smirked.
"Andy," he whispered.
"Hmm?"
"I love you."
"I love you too." He wrapped his arms around me and pulled me down to him. I smiled. He grabbed onto my hips and kissed me. I kissed him back. He slipped his sweatpants off. I smirked.
"What're you smirking at?"
"Nothing."
"Andyyy."
"What?" He pulled on my underwear.
"Heh."
"Take them off," he whispered.
"What if I don't want to?"
"Well, you don't have to if you don't want to."
"You're sweet, but I will." He blushed.
I took them off.
"Goddamn." I blushed. "You're so fucking beautiful."
"...th-thanks." He pulled me down to kiss me. I smiled into the kiss. He trailed his hands down my sides, squeezing my bum. I started to kiss down his chest. He moaned softly.
"I love you."
"I love you more." I yawned a little. "Baby, are you sleepy?"
"Lil bit."
"Why don't we just head to bed, okay?"
"Okay." I laid down on top of him. He chuckled and wrapped his arms around me after pulling the blanket over us. I went to sleep.
