Everyday at 3:30, a group of preppy girls strut into the usually quiet local coffee shop. They all seem like the same stereotypical popular girls to outsiders. But Hudson, the barista, sees something in Mariah. He catches her staring sometimes and she flashes Hudson smiles from across the room. Even though they've never had a full conversation, he lies awake at night thinking of her. Will Hudson ever get the courage to strike up a conversation, or will Mariah be the one who got away?