Select All
  • Strange Love (Eyeless jack X reader)
    63.9K 1.4K 13

    SOOOO you just gotta read to find out lololollllll Ye Imma annoy ya with that But come on, you fall in love with a killer that has to be some strange love yo (All credits to artist of cover)

    Completed  
  • creepypasta x male reader one shots
    494K 7.7K 69

    randomness, yoai don't like don't read

  • eyeless jack x Depressed seme male reader
    62.5K 1.2K 10

    this is just a story about ej and a male reader soo enjoy peeps.

  • Brother...? {Creepypasta x Male reader}
    97K 2.1K 11

    Slenderman has three brothers correct? but what if there was another far younger than the four of them living somewhere around the world waiting for him like he promised 20 years ago...the four of them were all in some point cold but not to M/n

  • Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios (male reader)
    64.6K 1.4K 11

    There's not many male reader creepypasta boyfriend scenarios, so I decided to write one myself. I hope you enjoy it.

  • A Killers Love (A Jeff the Killer X Male Reader Original)
    70.2K 1.6K 9

    You lay in bed contemplating what you will do tomorrow with your friends but hear the sound of glass smashing downstairs so you go and investigate, you freeze on the spot as you come face to face with Jeff the Killer

  • Creepypasta males x male reader
    77K 1.3K 4

    Here ya guys (like 1 person) go :3 Jeff x anorexic male reader Eyeless Jack x blind male reader BEN x new kid male reader Ticci Toby x shy male reader

  • Masky X Male Reader[COMPLETED]
    91.3K 1.6K 30

    This is a Masky X Male Reader. There will be a lot of lemons in this! (You and Masky are the Yaoi and some other Pastas) Don't read this if you are 13 years or older. Take my warning!.. Please? You was always loved by your parents. After your parents death, a 12 year old girl walked up to your doorstep---could your pa...

    Completed  
  • creepypasta x cannibal male reader
    234K 3.6K 20

    this will be a range of creepypastas x male reader one shots or fluff and shit like that.