What if Christine had a change of heart before it was too late? What if she chose Erik? What if Raoul learns to move on? Christine chooses Erik at the final lair scene and Erik doesn't let her go so easily. Raoul gets another girl. But is everyone happy?

Love, lies, seduction, and deceit. Christine Daae, put the events of the Opera Populaire behind her and went on to marry Raoul. But three years later she still can't shake the feelings for her angel of music and decides to do what her heart says, she leaves Raoul. She is finally reunited with her angel of music, but things don't go right. From jealous lovers to close calls with death, Christine's love for Erik is put to the test. What will happen to them? I do not own Phantom of the Opera. *Copyright all characters created by me are mine*

Passion, betrayal, desire, seduction, revenge. I had never meant to betray him. My entire childhood was spent loving him, wanting to be perfect for him. So why did I leave him for another man? But I am determined to fix this, to right the wrong I made that terrible night. And now I will follow him anywhere he asks me to go without a second thought. I will become his on this beautiful moonless night. I do not own Phantom of the Opera. All characters created by me are mine.

((Currently, I am rewriting this story to fit my current writing style, given this was written when I was in high school and I am in college now. There are a lot of changes, but I am leaving the original because I still like looking back on it. You can find the new & improved rewrite here: https://www.wattpad.com/433738666-an-opera-ghost-a-phantom-of-the-opera-fanfiction )) Florence was supposed to be the first child to Raoul and Christine de Chagny. Sadly, that wasn't the case. From the moment her parents saw her black eyes they knew Raoul was in no way the father. They knew it was the Phantom who had given Christine the child to make them suffer. Raoul, unable to keep this ghost of his past, takes Florence to the Opera Populaire knowing the Phantom still was lurking there as they tried to restore the place.The Phantom was in fact still there and he gladly took his daughter, hoping to raise her to be one of the opera's greatest singers. And as she grew, it was obvious his plans would succeed. But when Florence begins to fall for one of her patrons, will the Phantom allow her to love? *Just so you know, this is not just about the Phantom's daughter, but also about the Phantom himself, the Giry's, and the de Chagny's*

What if in the final lair scene of Phantom of the Opera Christine makes a different decision? But what if this decision is the wrong one? Or maybe The phantom won't accept her love. And if he does will it last?