Creepypasta (and some MH characters thrown in there too)
33 stories
Sin and Penance [Eyeless Jack x Reader] by Jcreeps
Sin and Penance [Eyeless Jack x Reader]
Jcreeps
  • Reads 18,708
  • Votes 1,070
  • Parts 6
A blind date goes horribly wrong and you find yourself in the hands of a demon-worshipping cult, bent on using you for a sacrifice. A strange creature in a blue mask saves you from your death, but not the bizarre effects of the ritual. Sharp teeth growing in, black tar endlessly oozing from your eye socket, bizarre new cravings... Your only hope for answers is to find Eyeless Jack. But how do you track someone who was never supposed to be found?
Then beg (Eyeless Jack x reader) by ingalollol
Then beg (Eyeless Jack x reader)
ingalollol
  • Reads 34,031
  • Votes 883
  • Parts 13
It started stupidly. A friend getting too much into it and then a murder spree. People always say that begging for your life wouldn't work in the real world. Oh, how you wished they were right. Olivia Series 3
Witness {Eyeless Jack x Reader} by LadyUrbosa
Witness {Eyeless Jack x Reader}
LadyUrbosa
  • Reads 2,161
  • Votes 88
  • Parts 2
I am continuing this book. The original book will be found by Glis @cybrochisFTW. I was granted permission to continue this book, I'm not sure how this book will turn out. It may be trash, but hey! I'm trying!! (;-;)
Witness {Eyeless Jack x Reader} by CybrochisFTW
Witness {Eyeless Jack x Reader}
CybrochisFTW
  • Reads 124,226
  • Votes 3,487
  • Parts 18
This story is not my own, i was granted permission from the true author of this story, i will soon put his/her username in the bottom of this page, But please, this story is amazing, i really enjoyed it and i hope you do too. Enjoy this amazing Eyeless Jack x Reader!! Warning! I have not read the ENTIRE story yet, i still have a few chapters to go. So i am not for SURE isf there's Gore/smutty parts, so be warned! Deviantart: yanderexprince (the true writer of this story!)
Lady Luck: Hoodie x Reader by Apple_Chips
Lady Luck: Hoodie x Reader
Apple_Chips
  • Reads 184,585
  • Votes 7,864
  • Parts 28
I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/
Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader by Apple_Chips
Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader
Apple_Chips
  • Reads 3,779,802
  • Votes 141,699
  • Parts 57
I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/
The First and The Last (A Creepypasta X Reader) by reastabc
The First and The Last (A Creepypasta X Reader)
reastabc
  • Reads 273,172
  • Votes 7,678
  • Parts 28
This is a story about Slenderman's first proxy. Now, of course, this story must start at the beginning, when he first meets you. Set in the 1800s, you meet Slenderman after running away from some men and into the nearby forest. After about 200 years, when Masky, Hoodie, and Toby are his proxies, he assigns them a difficult task. A task to find this "runaway proxy" and bring her back. But when they do, they realize they've got a very, very hard decision to make, and...well, I wouldn't want to ruin the plot. Also, I want to thank @Taylor_loveDun for helping me out with this book!
Fragile Heart by Peppapiglife
Fragile Heart
Peppapiglife
  • Reads 113
  • Votes 5
  • Parts 3
Forced to be a lab rat for her entire life, Y/n lives a miserable and crushing existence. Longing for death, her misery caught the attention of a certain smiling psycho. Will he fulfill her request in her lust for death and salvation or is she just his toy?
BOOK II: To Live with Ourselves by Jcreeps
BOOK II: To Live with Ourselves
Jcreeps
  • Reads 26,114
  • Votes 1,357
  • Parts 2
Jeff is back by popular demand, in a sequel for To Live without Fear! You and Jeff have settled into your life together, hopping from place to place, going wherever the wind takes you. You haven't had many run-ins with the law ever since you escaped from the mental hospital and Jane's wrath, but there are other, stranger consequences to living with an infamous serial killer, and these consequences come in the form of Jeremy MacArthur. COVER ART BY A-SLEEPLESS-DEATH ON TUMBLR
To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader] by Jcreeps
To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader]
Jcreeps
  • Reads 1,084,675
  • Votes 40,681
  • Parts 28
The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about fear. He was an artisan, and fear was his craft. Until the day he met the girl who didn't feel fear at all. COVER ART BY KAWACY ON DEVIANTART