Peter always goes for the spontaneous outspoken girls that arrive at his island. Girls are rarely brought to Neverland. But a girl who's so broken comes along, how does he get through to her. She's quite, skilled, does her job without questioning Peter. Peter thinks he could be falling for this girl, that is, until another one comes to the island. This one is like his usual Lost Girls, but does he want the usual or take a risk? His usual Lost Girls have to be trained. But he doesn't train the quiet one. He leaves her alone and has Felix keep an eye on her. To Peter's surprise, she lets Felix in. Felix tells Peter everything he learns from her, in return....Peter seems to fall even deeper for her despite himself.

What if I told you Felix had a younger sister named Anne? And what if I told you that after Felix left to become a lost boy, Anne found a box filled of all Neverland secrets? What if finally--when Pan plays his special song, Anne follows it to go find her brother? Pan doesn't approve of girls but can he resist taking Anne away to Neverland after he finds out shes the sister to one of his excellent lost boys? At war with Henry's saviors...Pan might just need another soldier...but what happens when love stands in the way of it all? And there's a reason why Pan doesn't approve of lost girls... "Tell me..." Pan started sliding his hand down Anne's arm. She shoved his hand away. "Tell you what--" "Did you feel it--" "I felt nothing--" "--how much I wanted you? How much I wanted everything you could possibly offer--never had I been more attracted--" "I don't care!" Anne spat. "Oh but of course you do! Because you wanted me too...only for a moment but you wanted me." [This story is also on Quotev as well under the name Peter Pan's storyteller] (Completed w/a sequel)