"Leave them; they are blind guides. If a blind man leads a blind man, both will fall into a pit." Even after the death of her father, Rosalie Booker's life stayed mundane. Helping the new sheriff take over her father's position, dealing with the upkeep of the general store, going to church every sunday. Her life couldn't be anymore simple despite her blindness. When Father Paul Hill arrives in their small town on Crockett Island, Rosalie never expected how it would feel to emerge from Grace.

there are far worse things awaiting man than death. Midnight Mass

"Father Paul saw her, the embodiment of sin, but she looked like an angel in his eyes" When the 27 year old Elizabeth Bates returns to her hometown of Crockett after her adoptive mother's passing, she finds herself strangely drawn to the new priest, despite her tumultuous upbringing. Inspiration playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1dZb9cd7bWYp64hdovft0c?si=IiydkgzcTwC5nBXYmRlhAA

Father paul x reader Oneshots I do not own any of the characters of midnight mass it is only intended for creative purposes. I will try and make y/n as vague as possible in order for you to be included mkay ☺️

Crockett Island was a quiet place. Perfect for those wishing to get away from everything and live a peaceful, if mundane, life. That is until Father Paul Hill arrives with secrets that won't only affect his congregation but other innocents living on the island. (This story will contain spoilers.)