Select All
  • Jeff x reader Young Once
    13.3K 519 12

    You and your friend were always into the creepy side of things you even believed in "fake" myths or creatures that lurked on this world. Your life seems pretty normal and going well. You hang out with your best friend, go to school, do your chores, the norm. But when you come face to face with an insane killer, just h...

  • Masky X Hoodie X Gunslinger! Reader X Ticci-Toby
    15.1K 423 4

    Ellos I decided to do another Creepypasta but a Gunslinger Reader. Yush you are a gunslinger, awesome right?! Well I hope you guys like this story. ( Masky X Hoodie X Gunslinger!Reader X Ticci-Toby or Proxies X reader)

  • With Every Smile(jeff x reader)
    109K 3.5K 12

    It was EXTREMELY late, you had went to a friends 16 birthday party and on the way home you encountered someone breaking into your home! You rushed there you didn't find anything broken or taken until you went to your room. A man with a cut smile waited there. "Go to sleep." okay...you gonna stand there th...

    Completed  
  • Jeff x reader (Probably Ended)
    81.2K 2.4K 22

    Jeff x reader 2019 note here. I have no more ideas so this is on hold.

    Mature
  • Jeff × Reader: A Killer Love
    40.5K 802 36

    You were a high school student with a family that doesn't love you and with an abusive boyfriend. All you could remember is running through the woods while being chased from your boyfriend. You ended up being in a mansion belonging to Slenderman and his childrens and started getting chased by killers. You ended up kno...

  • The Psycho Kills (Reader X creepypasta) [Under Construction]
    141K 2.4K 58

    Y/n a eighteen year old lives alone, they were isolated and out casted when they were young because of some unusual gift. Her loneliness drove her insane. After running from parents they end up alone. During one of her "trips" she runs into the proxies, how will this turn out? will there be love interest? what trouble...

  • Meet by chance, love by choice (jeff x reader)
    63.8K 2K 21

    A chance meeting with none other than jeff the killer changes your life forever. WARNING: there is strong language used in this story. There may also be sexual content if people ask or I feel like it.

  • Jeff x Reader
    38.1K 905 17

    "You fucker you hit me with a plastic bat!' "I Sure did sweetheart." the killer smiled..."bastard..... " you murmured... I was trapped in a mansion with creepypastas everywhere.. what was I gonna do?

  • Jeff (the killer) x reader (on hold til march 2018 or sooner)
    208K 5.8K 34

    find yourself in love with one of the creepypasta name Jeff the killer. Are you ready to go through the crazyness to be with your love?

  • Proxy Problems (Creepypasta x Reader)
    166K 3.6K 18

    (Y/N) was a normal, orphaned teenager. She had a bunch of disorders, her mother was dead, her father was... gone. She was alone, but she was happy. Although... One day, three proxies came into her life, and everything was turned upside down. Is this change a good thing... or bad?

    Completed  
  • Carved Happiness ( Jeff the Killer x reader )
    405K 11K 43

    This is by no means a story of which a girl falls in love with this amazing, hot serial killer who is so protective of her in the slender mansion. This is twisted story. A story of gore and sociopathy details that gives the real meaning of Jeff the killer, a mad man who barely feels anything who somehow feels a slithe...

    Completed  
  • Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader)
    188K 5.2K 26

    What will happen when you meet Toby Rogers? You read that right! The Toby Rogers, better known as Ticci Toby, a very well known killer. Will you geek out? Will you get killed? Will you fall in love? Or will you hate him? Find out in this adventurous fanfiction! {I do NOT own any of the creepypastas, nor do I own...

    Completed  
  • Saved (ticci toby x reader) discontinued
    96.2K 2.7K 53

    Running, that's what you've done for a while now. You're abusive boyfriend is chasing you. Why, you ran away from him again. He's right behind you now and before he could grab you a blood curdling scream rang out.

  • I'm Falling For You (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    153K 5.3K 71

    "AHHHHH!" You screamed as you fell "THIS WAS A TERRIBLE IDEA!" You see light as you keep falling and soon find yourself being launched in the air. You thankfully grab onto a branch still holding onto the bag of items. You look down and gulp. "What now?" You growled looking for a way down to the dirt without falling...

    Completed   Mature
  • Under Control (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    214K 6.4K 37

    (May contain sensitive topics) Things never went as plan as (Y/n) hoped. Her family had dissipated, leaving her with her solemn aunt. There, she was alone and liked it that way. When she had developed bad habits of drinking, she was falling into her crumbling world. When someone pops up in her home, her world flips an...

    Completed  
  • Savior 》Ticci Toby x Reader {EDITING}
    546K 19.4K 23

    ~"The wind tugged at your hair as you sat on a bench and read your book. You had an uneasy feeling, like you were being watched, but you ignored it. You didn't know he was behind you."~ Living with your drunken mother had been a living hell. Everyday, you wished for nothing more than to leave. One night when you're ho...

    Completed  
  • Jeff the killer X reader LEMON
    17.9K 218 2

    idk what im doing with my life right now but here's a lemon/smut

    Completed   Mature
  • Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    1.6M 51.5K 37

    A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderm...

    Completed  
  • Jeff the killer x reader LEMON (UNDER EDITING!!!)
    25.3K 341 8

    Your a crazy maniac that lives in a asylum. Your overly obsessed with creepypasta, or I should say Jeff. One night a particular person kidnaps you, well, you let him. And that person is Jeff the killer.

    Completed   Mature
  • Mad House (Jeff the Killer X reader)
    776K 24.8K 28

    Jeff the killer x reader Is it possible for you to fall in love with an insane killer?

    Completed   Mature
  • You're my new game. Ben drowned x reader.
    992K 26.6K 29

    A story about a boy. And you. Read on to find out more!

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby x reader
    335K 6.6K 28

    (Y/A) year old (y/n) walks home one night after a total fail on a date with the person who you thought she loved. The boy Zach told her to leave and never speak to him ever again. You left and walked home crying, but you stumbled in a forest to be tackled by a stranger.

    Completed  
  • Masky X Reader
    9.3K 273 13

    this is my first story so please, no hating! I hope you enjoy this small novel!

  • To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader]
    1M 40.5K 28

    The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about fear. He was an artisan, and fear was his craft. Until the day he met the girl who didn't feel fear at all. COVER ART BY KAWACY ON DEVIANTART

  • As long as your with us (Proxies X Reader
    19.5K 312 12

    I have nothing to say but all i know is that what im gonna do is stupid oh, and the proxies are only Toby, masky and hoodie no Jeff or any other pasta.....btw...... WELCOME TO THE MOST SHITTIEST AND CRINGY STORY EVER!!

    Completed  
  • New Town (offenderman x Reader)
    569K 14K 52

    Im a nobody in my old town, in fact people hated me because they hated the way I joked about what lunatics do. Well sorry I turn the bad into funny. My only friend was Becky and she moved to New York with her boyfriend. So since I was a hated by everyone in town I moved to an unmarked town. Population 83, well 84 now...

    Completed  
  • What Hurts the Most(Jeff the killer x Reader)
    38.6K 1.4K 13

    (Y/n)'s life has always been shit. She has been used, abused, and neglected. She always felt as if she was never wanted, and of course others have told her that she's being ridiculous, but the way everyone treated her made her think it's all bullshit. But what happens when a certain killer takes interest in the young...

  • human smile dog x reader: I Smile When I See your face
    24.2K 511 7

    OK guys you asked for a smile dog x reader story and here it is hope you enjoyed!

  • My Psycho Love
    2.3K 68 3

    Jane X Fem!Reader. (Y/N) has been stalked by Jane for weeks. She caught onto her around the first week, after realizing that jane wasn't going to kill her she was calm around Jane. Ever now and then I just want to mention this is hot garbage, like looking back on it now almost three years after originally writing it I...

    Completed  
  • Jane X Female reader
    201K 4.7K 16

    You are hated by your homophobic parents, one night you were asleep until you heard someone come through your window. That's when your life changed

    Completed