{Benny "the Jet" Rodriguez x reader} This is my first story so sorry if it's kind of trashy :D I've seen many Benny Fics that are not x reader so I decided to make one myself for you guys to enjoy ~Story takes place in the 90's~ "Before you speak don't move cause I don't wanna wake up.." You moved from Manhattan, New York to California(I know the sandlot is in Utah but In this story it will be in Cali)and met this group of guys that clearly play baseball. Personally you love baseball and softball and used to play for your school. You go outside to your yard and meet both Benny and Smalls. They ask if you'd like to play with the guys and you finally agreed. You then began to catch feelings for him and you come across a situation that brings you all together. Hope you like it :) I do not own the sandlot characters Completed✅ Highest placement: #2 bennyxreader #1 bennyxreader

What if sandlot wasn't a big group of boys? What if there was a girl on the team? Would it change at all or would it stay the same?Catherine Smalls, a 14 year old girl who, unlike her brother, Scotty, knows a lot about baseball. Benjamin Rodrigues, a 14 year old boy who eats, breaths, and sleeps Baseball. When Scotty is accepted into a group of boys who play never ending games of baseball she stays in the background and watches from a distance. Soon, she is caught and Benny Rodrigues has her join the team as a "punishment". They decide that she has to join the team or Smalls is kicked off. She accepts the challenge. The punishment soon turns into a chance for everyone to fall in love with Catherine. The only, problem is Catherine then, has to choose between eleven different boys. Can she choose between them without hurting them? Or will this break up the game? Will she choose Benjamin Rodrigues, the boy she likes?Stay tuned to find out in "The Sandlot Girl: Small's Sister"