Hailey was a simple 'average' girl. By average I mean she is a foster child for 6 years, moving from family to family. She finally got a 'family' that has kept her for a year; which she was surprised cause she was usually kept for a month or two. She always like creepypasta stories, she thought they were cute and funny. She knew that they were real, but she didn't expect to be almost killed by one. And in her eyes he was beautiful; in his eyes she was perfect.

whisp is a 17 year old girl with silver hair with dark green eyes and she always wears a black shirt with a creeper on it with blue jeans. you guys should know what toby wears.

Kaley doesn't like to be scared at all. She can't even watch scury movies without being scured. Toby has been watching her for a while and he knows this. He decides that instead of just simply killing her, he's going to play a little game with her.

A young girl by the name of Allison Hill and her family went missing, two years later, Allison shows up on the doorstep of an elderly couple. Taking her in, they asked what had happened to her family, and she replied, "I watched him do it. He killed them. He killed them all." When asked who killed them she replied in a deathly quiet whisper, "Jeff killed them." The older couple took pity on the girl, she had been alone for so long her mind made up a story as to how her family died, only she didn't make it up. ------------------- "They think I'm crazy, out of my mind, insane, but, I swear I'm not. I've seen him, and what he does. He's real, Jeff is real, and he's the only one who can help me now." -Allison Hill -------------------------- Allison was taken to the mental hospital by the elderly couple because they were concerned about her. She understands why they did it. She wouldn't believe herself if she didn't know it was true. But the thing is... Allison wants Jeff to kill her. She doesn't want to live anymore, and maybe, just maybe Jeff will let her, 'go to sleep'.

Toby x Reader

Dagger meets Toby and the rest of the creepypasta's. She starts to fall in love with Toby and Toby starts to fall in love with her, her father the devil himself tells her that she can't fall in love but I mean who listens to their fathers anyway. Many things happen that people would never even wish on their enemy's now read this story to find out how Dagger and Toby make it through