Flannery Caraway liked to imagine that she’d forgotten all about her former best friend, Nate Gray. But if she were to do that, she’d be lying. Flannery had left Nate and her old home in the suburbs when she was whisked away to Manhattan in first grade when her father landed a promotion in New York City. But now that her parents have divorced and her mother gotten custody, her mother’s decided to get back to their roots and move back to their old home in suburban New Jersey. But when she’s reunited with her old town, she’s also reunited with her old troubles, which includes Nate. Now, Nate has a new potential love interest, new friends, and a new personality entirely. Flannery, accompanied by her new friends, tries to discover whether or not the Nate she knew and love still exists, and if moving back to suburbia was really worth it in the end.