What if Spencer was kidnapped instead of Hanna? What if Toby and Yvonne broke up? What if Spencer and Toby got back together? "What if" is a really big two letter word. *I do not own pretty little liars or the characters.

When two brothers move two Rosewood, Toby and Wren, they will have to fight for the love of Spencer Hastings. Who will Spencer choose? Read to find out.

What if instead of getting shot, Spencer got kidnapped by AD and Jenna didn't, Toby and Yvonne got in a terrible car crash that nearly killed them both and the almost dead experience made Toby realize he was denying the odvious fact that he still loves Spencer so as soon as he's realised from the hospital he goes looking for her and the only thing he finds is an open investigation, will Toby be the one to save her or will Marco beat him to the punch?

When Toby's fiancé Yvonne is injured when 'A' breaks in to get charlottes radley file, Spencer meets Toby at the hospital telling him that him and Yvonne need to get out because she is tired of seeing people she loves get hurt. After Toby thinks this through he goes to Spencer's barn to tell her the truth. 'I wasn't building he house for Yvonne, I was building it for you' Spencer new what he was going to say. He was leaving with Yvonne to live somewhere else. She said goodbye but he wasn't leaving yet, she needs to tell him the truth.

Toby moves in next door to spencer they have created a friendship but Toby has developed feelings for spencer. Does spencer feel the same?

-Emison Duh! -Based off the AU I have done on Instagram. -Emily is Intersex (if that's not your thing, don't read) -Follow my Instagram @emisonzau