Every school has a weird kid, well subjectively speaking. But Toby isn't weird in someone's eyes, he's kind, cool and funny. It felt like a light poking from a cracked window, but of course- the gloomy clouds just had to ruin everything for him. And years later... he found his light again. Except that light has no idea where is shining. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ⚠️‼️Ticci Toby x fem!Reader ‼️⚠️ english is not my first language i don't have a post schedule everything u need to know is in the notes (the first thing)

What is wrong with you? Why are you in love with a hatchet throwing killer? Why does hurting people feel so.. satisfying? And why does this guy GET it? You did something bad. Really bad. You know it's wrong and it feels wrong but.. something deep inside you likes it. Couldn't you just have a better hobby? No, of course not! Instead your best hobby is murder, which is why now you're in this house full of psychos like you. Maybe that's why you've been hanging out with this one psycho and found him to be pretty interesting as you adjust to a new life as a malevolent entities killer. Disclaimer! All characters in this are not my own! Each creepypasta or proxy was made by someone else. This is just a story I'm writing. This is just fanfiction for me and anyone who wants to enjoy it! Some people forgot that. If this isn't your thing you are free to click away. Please no hate. This fic is a mix of the best aspects of the pastas or what I find interesting that works for the story narratively and character-wise. Also I shouldn't have to say this bc it's Creepypasta but this obviously has death, murder, violence, cursing, trauma, misplaced morals, manipulation and other bad stuff. Idk why your reading this if your cool with Creepypasta since they're basically synonymous with these things, but if this if not you're thing, again, click away and protect your peace. (I've been in this fandom so long!! Just got dragged back please send help ToT)

(A Dark Ticci Toby x Reader) *Original Version They were after you. You weren't sure why, nothing really made sense. Somehow they were convinced you knew something, they wanted answers; answers you didn't have. After being kidnapped, abused, and interrogated; you were more then ready to give up. That was until he came along, sparking a little bit of hope inside your beaten and tired form. You couldn't just give up, couldn't give them that satisfaction. You'd get through this. Alive. (Rated M for violence, strong language, sexual/suggestive themes) Cover image by Jordan Persegati

This is a Jennifer's Body inspired story that includes you- the creature x Toby! After a 'date' goes wrong and you end up as a sacrifice for a shitty band you... come back.

A lot changed after the fire. You never forgot about Toby. Toby on the other hand was a different story. He moved in with a girl, and changed his life, for, what seems, the better. Will Toby be able to remember you, and his true feelings? ⋆ You're A Nightmare Part 2 ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader

Unfortunately Tobias Rogers needs help, and your the only one who can help him. But that doesn't mean either of you will enjoy your time spent together. Will you be able to get over your dislike and realize your true feelings? Ticci Toby X Reader

(✔️finished) They met in a grocery store. she accidentally hit him with a coke and then didn't stop talking. but will they meet again and what happens if she finds out about his true identity? Only one way to find out ;) pronouns of y/n are she/her but the gender doesn't affect the story so it can still be read if you use other pronouns (if you don't mind reading she/her)

This book had depictions of abuse and toxic relationships. It's not a book that should be fetishized, I think that this is how the creepypastas would actually treat you if you were captured. Please read with caution.