Greyson adopts a child while working with Augustine not understanding she was also supernatural. Damon has never come across anything like her before and becomes intrigued while she has spent her whole life fighting her true nature and it's a very hard habit to break.

There's more to Caroline's sister than what meets the eye. Returning from a boarding school that her parents sent her to, Lillian comes back to Mystic Falls anything but quietly. With one look at the Forbes sister, the Salvatore brothers forget all about the doppelgänger. After fighting for affection from Katherine and Elena, the brother take a different approach. What if they both had her?