Kaitlyn never really trusted her best friend Leah's boyfriend- Jared. He's the most popular guy at River View High, the typical 'It' guy. The guy that can get any girl with just the snap of his fingers, the guy that can get anything that he desires with just a smile, the guy who is ruining Kaitlyn's life just because she's trying to show his true colors. Jared's not the sweet and sensitive guy that everyone thinks he is, he's a two-timing Cheater. When Kaitlyn finds out Jared's cheating ways, she takes drastic measures to keep Leah's heart from breaking. But what happens when Jared finds out about her plan? Will her plans backfire or will she be able to keep it up and prove that Once a Cheater, Always A Cheater?

**WINNER of The People's Choice Watty Award** Finn Harlow met his soulmate in kindergarten, but fate wasn't kind and she ended up marring his best friend. After years of watching in silent agony, he's certain he's met a girl who can finally mend his broken heart--until he finds her in the arms of her lover. In walks Holden Drake; dark, mysterious, and dripping in confidence. All the things Finn wishes he was. He promises to turn Finn into a modern-day Casanova and offers a guarantee that no woman will leave Finn again. But something about Holden doesn't seem right and the deeper Finn pries, the more he stumbles into a world of sex and scandal, leaving him forced to decide if he will risk it all to chase his first love, or succumb to the invitation and join Holden's club.