All Payjay Oneshots/Fanfics/Comics/Ratings/Opinions I could find
200 stories
Folded Edges [PAYJAY FANFIC] by lumityshipperdork35
Folded Edges [PAYJAY FANFIC]
lumityshipperdork35
  • Reads 509
  • Votes 2
  • Parts 6
this is a payjay fanfic yeah uh idk what I'm gonna do about this also sorry the writing is bad and I might forget when to post Im prob gonna have to be killed after writing this
I'm Sick, Save Me. (A PayJay Hanahaki FanFic) by thelifeofowen
I'm Sick, Save Me. (A PayJay Hanahaki FanFic)
thelifeofowen
  • Reads 2,206
  • Votes 32
  • Parts 11
Maybe our villains aren't that other side living in us, Maybe they're just us.
+10 more
Coping-Payjay and other II ships by Em_4X2
Coping-Payjay and other II ships
Em_4X2
  • Reads 2,070
  • Votes 32
  • Parts 33
I rlly suck at writing Payjay :c
Letters Never Sent. -Payjay by Marxx_y
Letters Never Sent. -Payjay
Marxx_y
  • Reads 3,713
  • Votes 56
  • Parts 8
Paper and Salt love OJ, and OJ is going to choose only one, but in ended very bad, watch it to know more! -Payjay Warnings: Abuse, kidnapping, torture, sensitive
Lies are Sweeter than Silence by TallLiar
Lies are Sweeter than Silence
TallLiar
  • Reads 137
  • Votes 5
  • Parts 1
OJ and Paper have been together for a while now. But lately OJ's been drowning in his manager duties, oblivious to the way he neglects his lover. He doesn't notice his behaviour until the world he used to cherish comes crashing down around him, and the reality of the situation finally comes to light. [Originally Posted to AO3!]
Payjanuary! (A month of Payjay fluff) by TallLiar
Payjanuary! (A month of Payjay fluff)
TallLiar
  • Reads 13,426
  • Votes 181
  • Parts 30
I love payjay, a lot! Especially fluffy payjay! So, I decided I'd start writing a short Payjay drabble every day for a month and chuck it at the world, because why not? Buckle up, because it's Payjanuary! - This fic was originally written, chapter by chapter, on AO3! One of my friends suggested dumping it all on Wattpad after it was done sooooo!! :) The oneshots start out super short but get longer as I became a more confident writer. The last chapter is literally over 10x longer than the first I mean what is this shi (Also, if you saw this back when I uploaded it with just 4 parts to its name... no you didn't)
Love at Hotel OJ (PayJay) by GayLover3721
Love at Hotel OJ (PayJay)
GayLover3721
  • Reads 8,872
  • Votes 230
  • Parts 50
OJ and paper have been enjoying themselves at hotel OJ during season 2 of inanimate insanity. OJ being the one that runs the hotel most of the time but paper being his best friend helps out a lot. but both paper and OJ caught feelings for each other after years of being best friends? how would they confess how would they weather the storm? how are they going to deal with salt that is becoming psychopathic? would there love for each other go on? Tags: as of September 17 2025 #1 Paper #2 testtube #4 OJ #9 objectshow #10 salt #11 payjay #17 ii #22 gayfic BTW characters are not humanified This is a fan fiction story based off on Inanimate Insanity. The world and all the characters are made by AnimationEpic not me. ( sorry the grammar is not going to be perfect especially in the earlier chapters. and this story might be cringe but your on Wattpad what did you expect.) warning 🚨 strong language/slurs/violance/attempted suicide/and smut if you don't like any of these things just don't read the story
payjay oneshots⁉️⁉️ by St4rBot
payjay oneshots⁉️⁉️
St4rBot
  • Reads 1,214
  • Votes 4
  • Parts 8
idk dude I'm not a great writer so don't burn me at the stake please💔💔
Totally platonic +{A PayJay highschool AU}+ by Lifebrush
Totally platonic +{A PayJay highschool AU}+
Lifebrush
  • Reads 5,217
  • Votes 58
  • Parts 9
Paper and OJ have been friends for a while now, but these weird feelings keep arising when they're near... strange, I wonder what the feeling is? This is not my first fanfiction, but it is my first fanfiction on Wattpad, and including inanimate insanity, there will be no smut or anything because I am only a teenager, and I am uncomfortable with writing that. (This is also high school; they are minors.) Other ships, PayJay-centric though!! half chatfic!! Very OOC!! It is slightly bad, mostly near the start, it gets better though, trust.
When Workaholics fall in love.. || PayJay Fanfic by YoleCake2763
When Workaholics fall in love.. || PayJay Fanfic
YoleCake2763
  • Reads 348
  • Votes 10
  • Parts 2
PayJay dump bc i have a hyper fixation and I'm making it you guys' problem Characters belong to AnimationEpic!!