With the help of her best male friend, Taylor, vintage toy seller Nina Cox creates a dating profile to fulfill her family's challenge of going on ten dates. Navigating the dating scene within the geek community proves to be tricky, as her dates include Star Wars enthusiasts, Harry Potter look-alikes, Dungeons and Dragons role players, and Halo gamers. Although Nina has never been particularly close to falling in love, perhaps she just needs to look right in front of her.

Nico Durant is living a lonely life as the remaining member of his household. Not only did his twin sister and best friend move away, but he's also recovering from the wounds his ex-girlfriend caused. Olivia Paz is the mysterious new girl on campus everyone is talking about. But she only has two goals in her life: working through college, and taking care of her dad. When Olivia finds herself in trouble, Nico can't avoid helping her, even if it means jeopardizing his new status as captain of the soccer team. Nico's past unexpectedly catches up with him, and he must decide whether he's capable of letting Olivia go, or loving her.