Select All
  • Carved Happiness ( Jeff the Killer x reader )
    404K 11K 43

    This is by no means a story of which a girl falls in love with this amazing, hot serial killer who is so protective of her in the slender mansion. This is twisted story. A story of gore and sociopathy details that gives the real meaning of Jeff the killer, a mad man who barely feels anything who somehow feels a slithe...

    Completed  
  • Freak Show (Jeff the Killer X reader) Book 1
    193K 7.8K 24

    *Book 1* Living in a Freak Show is like living in hell, but can a Joker wannabe change it all?

    Completed   Mature
  • Unhealthy love: Jeff the killer x reader
    18.3K 364 27

    A lonely girl suddenly discovers her parents aren't who she thought they were when she meets a certain killer. She makes the biggest mistake by allowing that killer to enter her life and makes her question her own sanity. This is my first time writing and publishing in wattpad, I am sorry if it's not well made I will...

    Completed   Mature
  • That One Killer |Jeff The Killer x Reader
    1.1K 7 38

    When you and Jeff were friends before he went insane he got bullied during it you helped him with it crap he's been going and while you had family issues during it Months went by and now you ended up forgetting about him then one day you were home alone cause a trip your parents went then hearing a knock at the door...

    Completed  
  • You're a Sharp One (Jeff the Killer X Female! Killer! Reader)
    316K 7.6K 25

    "Now now.." Jeff's gruff voice whispered into your ear as he pinned you against the wall of your bedroom walls with his knife pressed against your neck. "You're always complaining how no one can catch you, but, you seem so frightened, with my knife against your [skin toned] neck. Face it. You're destined to death," he...

    Completed  
  • Mad House (Jeff the Killer X reader)
    775K 24.8K 28

    Jeff the killer x reader Is it possible for you to fall in love with an insane killer?

    Completed   Mature
  • Obey My Words ( yandere Jeff the killer X reader) (under construction)
    159K 3.8K 23

    (Y/n) just moved out of her parents house, after turning 18 and then having her parents give her the final nudge out of the best she hit hard, bills, money, food..... And a psychopathic killer at her door

    Mature
  • Jeff The Killer X Reader - I'll love you for all eternity
    282K 7.6K 48

    (Y/n) is what people qualify as an average teenager. Going to school, meeting friends and hanging out with her boyfriend. But what makes (Y/n) different is her past. She hasn't told anyone, and everything that happened in the first 13 years of her life are a mystery to all. Until a meet up with a certain someone bring...

    Completed  
  • Just my type | Jeff the killer x reader
    218K 4.2K 28

    Hey guys, this is my first and oldest story, so dont expect too much. Y/N is a female with she/her pronouns (I wrote this when I was like 10) ⚠Contains language, gore & murder, assault, and smut⚠ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

  • Yandere Jeff The Killer x reader (Lemon)
    443K 7.7K 39

    What happens when a sassy girl, with a swearing habit, meets a forever smiling killer, with a strange obsession over her? Will he kill her if she doesn't listen to him? Or does she fall for the killer with a forever smile Warning swearing, sexual scenes, triggers I don't own creepypasta or you

    Completed   Mature
  • I can't decide (A Jeff the Killer x Reader x Eyeless Jack story)
    113 4 3

    You have been kidnapped along with other teens, forced to go to what they called school. One day you finally snap. You run, meet people, maybe join a group of murderers... and two special people... Can you guess? What happens to you?! Read to find out!

    Mature
  • Sins [Jeff the killer x reader]
    136K 3.9K 19

    Jeff attempts to kill you, but you almost kill him instead. [abandoned]

  • Jeff x Reader - Partners in Crime (Discontinued)
    30.3K 818 8

    A Jeff x Reader story. In this story you meet Jeff the Killer and he confesses his undying love for you. You must must fight to manage a relationship with a murderer. Will you be the one murdered? Or the murderer?

    Completed  
  • cut love ( a Jeff the killer X reader X eyeless jack
    6.9K 158 10

    so, you were a new creepypasta, and your best friend out of the pastas was trap. she thought it was a good idea to play truth or dare, but at the end of the game, you find out you not only have 1 admirer, but 2. Who will choose? Can you choose? WARNING! VIOLENT LANGUAGE, LITTLE SEXUAL CONTENT, 12+

  • Another || Jeff the killer × OC × Eyeless Jack
    1.4K 173 54

    It's triangle love. Contains some mature things. Read story to find more! Started:April-4-2023 Finished:May-13-2023

    Completed   Mature
  • Trick And Kill~~Jeff The Killer X Reader X Eyeless Jack
    848K 25.9K 77

    How much can a human take before the reality around him snaps? For you it was the most unbearable loss of them all. It was more than enough to drown everything sane inside of you. The monster rose inside of you and everything went up to flames. But you are not alone. Madness knows no limits. The same goes for love.~~...

    Completed   Mature
  • Smile (Jeff the killer X Reader)
    369K 8.9K 19

    A love story between two twisted hearts. As your world falls apart you meet the famous serial killer Jeff. What will happen? *Warning: contains violence and lemon*

    Completed   Mature
  • The Game [Jeff The Killer x Reader]
    430K 17.2K 37

    I wasn't sure what love was. Everyone spoke of it like a legend. Something sacred that you'd capture if you were lucky. The man I had let take my heart wanted to carve it out of my chest as proof. I tried to forget feeling that way about him. I tried to figure out why I could ever love someone like him. He terrified m...

    Completed   Mature
  • Jeff the Killer x Reader
    31.3K 415 15

    Have you ever wondered how it would be like to fall in love with a killer? Well Lets just say someone sneeks to your room and has a sharp knife to your neck. but before you know it you were alive with a cut on you neck. Why? Read to find out

    Completed   Mature
  • Marked (Jeff the Killer X Reader)
    290K 9.1K 15

    It all stared with a simple visit. A visit that was supposed to kill you. That night you were left with a strange mark on your chest, and that night your life changed. COVER BY: SlaveForGoogle NOTE: This story is years old so there's bound to be plot holes and sometimes just bad writing. If you can look past all that...

    Completed  
  • I Found You {Jeff The Killer X Reader}
    294K 8.6K 17

    『 #8 ɪɴ ᴊᴇғғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪʟʟᴇʀ 』 The blood rushed over my body, heart beating, world spinning. It was a whole new world, I never knew something so bad could feel so good. The blood on my hands, the scream of their voices- I've done it. I've killed my first victims. This was the first murder in 2 years in our small town since...

    Completed