Elliot Jensen and Elliot Fintry have a lot in common. They share the same name, the same house, the same school, oh and they hate each other but, as they will quickly learn, there is a fine line between love and hate.

Slenderman's two proxies, Masky and Hoodie, have recently accomplished a mission. However, the immense guilt that Masky had for harming one of Tim's friends dangerously plagued his mind as he did something he thought he would never do. This mission wasn't like all of the other missions. This one had a price. A deadly one.