Paisley is in love with Zeke and anyone who comes between them and doesn't back off, well they're never heard of again. When Paisley made her first kill, she found out how much she enjoyed it and how it easy it was to get away with it. So for her there is no reason to stop the killing and it's an easy solution for her problem. But now with her latest victim, Trudy, things start to go wrong when the police are suspecting Zeke. Paisley can not let this happen and with every next decision she makes everything starts spiraling more and more out of control. Enter Damien, a boy who believes he's just like Paisley and he wants her badly. But she loves Zeke and will do anything for him, although she is not so immune to Damien as she likes to believe. If that's not enough problems, she is also stalked by the ghosts of her past kills. They are hiding in the mirrors and waiting for their chance for revenge.

Lexi Grayson is a normal teenager, as normal as she can be with her unobserving skills and her overthinking mind. But she might need the overthinking if she wants to unravel the smirking mystery that is Blake Eaton.