Lucy tries to juggle being a rookie while also carrying on a secret relationship with the station's captain, Zoe. When Lucy and her girlfriend break up, she and her recently divorced Training Officer, Tim, make a pact as members of their newly minted Broken Hearts Club to move on from their exes. Moving on, however, leads them to fall for each other. Yes, Chenford is endgame in this.

Lucy gets evicted from her apartment yet again, so in desperate need of a short term solution, she stays with Tim, but with feelings brewing between them, living together intensifies their connection. Canon divergent after 3x14. Title shares the name with a song by Taylor Swift.

Tim meets a cute stray cat that he swore he was not going to keep, but a beautiful vet named Lucy changes his mind.

Lucy complains about how her sex life with Chris is not fair, and Tim overhears the conversation, which was enough impetus to get him to talk about the one subject they never discussed before: sex. Soon enough, he gets to show her a fair sex life. Title shares the name with a song by Lily Allen.

Tim and Lucy's wedding day would not be true to them without a little mischief.

Lucy and the kids are all sick, ruining hers and Tim's date night plans, but it's not so bad. Title is lyrics from "All Of The Girls You Loved Before" by Taylor Swift.

Angela Lopez and Tim Bradford are best friends and step siblings, but they could not be any more different. While Tim's only concern is soccer, Angela wants to enjoy herself during her senior year of high school off of the soccer pitch. The new transfer student, Wesley Evers, shows interest in her immediately, and she would love to explore their connection further, but her stepdad has strictly forbidden her from dating in high school...unless Tim dates, too. The problem: absolutely no one is interested in dating him due to his gruff and grumpy demeanor. All hope of Wes and Angela being together seems lost until a plan is hatched to get Tim to date the nicest girl in school that he has absolutely nothing in common with aside from laser focus on her own goals: Lucy Chen. Title shares the name with a song by Letters to Cleo. Loosely based on the movie "10 Things I Hate About You".

Angela and Wes' initial wedding plans were foiled, but they still want to get married, so with Tim and Lucy's help, they finally tie the knot. Missing scene from 4x2

Lucy Chen literally stumbled upon the only person in Los Angeles that did not recognize her from her various infamous movie roles. As a bookstore owner and book lover, of course Tim Bradford was not a fan of movies nor did he know who starred in them, so when Lucy came into his store, he had no idea he was talking to one of the greatest actresses in the world. One chance meeting, akin to the ones in the movies, brought them together, but their story could be better than the kind shown on the silver screen. Title is the same name as a song by Taylor Swift.

Tim was lucky enough to have the day off on the L.A. Dodgers' Opening Day, and he watches the game with Lucy. Sexiness ensues.