Josh Keshet has been a loner almost all his life. He has only ever had one friend, Kaden Prich. Kaden moved away 5 years ago and left Josh all alone. Before he left he kissed Josh and told him he loved him. Now he's back. What will Josh do?

Brody Nelson is the king of his school, he has girls swooning over him, guys wanting to be him for just a day and a girlfriend everybody wishes they had. He hates his life. He lives a lie every day, putting on a mask for his friends and even family. Except for his sister Zoey. She’s the only one who knows the real him and sees what he does to change himself at school. It hurts her to see her brother change the way he is for some people, but there's nothing she can do… She knows Brody’s biggest fear is to lose his reputation though he will not admit it thinking nothing of it. But when he meets someone he’s willing to change for his fears become greater as he knows he must come out to the world. He knows his friends won’t accept him for being gay.

Alex thinks he has the perfect relationship with boyfriend Gary. When Dexter moves in next door to Alex, things start to get complicated. Everyone Dexter meets seems to develop feelings for him, and even though he's straight, Alex can't help but start to fall for him. These concerns he outlines in his brutally honest diary, while also dealing with his psychotic best friend Andie and his parents' divorce.