Select All
  • 𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader}
    76.5K 4.8K 37

    In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this...

    Completed   Mature
  • Creepypasta x male reader 😉(Book 1) {COMPLETED}
    195K 5.1K 47

    He has homicidal tendencies, he's incapable of feeling fear, and is the most powerful creepypasta to exist. How does he react when given the chance of a life time. Will he except his new roll, or will he abandon his destiny? *for mature audiences only* {I wrote this when I was like 14. Come, enjoy the extreme cringe w...

    Completed   Mature
  • In The Dark ( Creepypasta x Reader )
    931K 26K 47

    Knowing I burnt my house to ash? Living with that fact? That doesn't bother me. The punches and hits I receive? I couldn't care less. But this really fucking bothered me... (Warning, -Strong language -Gore -Sensitive content -The reader is written gender neutral so anyone can read it I use they/them pronouns) (Yes, I...

    Completed  
  • My Sunshine | Bloody Painter X Male! Reader
    110K 4.7K 33

    His h/c hair flowed into the classroom. His eyes bright and smile brighter. Helen thought he would go blind. This boy was as cheerful as the sun, and when the two made eye contact, Helen knew it would be troublesome. Y/N liked Helen, but Helen did not feel the same. He didn't know why y/n wanted to be his friend so ba...

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta X Male Reader
    55.4K 1.1K 21

    Reader your on a wild gurney to find Sally from creepypasta because your like her big bro. But after a deadly battle you have to wait a long time to see her again and before you could properly see her again is right after you see her get raped by her uncle. But for the third time you meet her again and she's already...

  • Creepypastas boyfriend scenarios
    94.3K 1.3K 20

    This is for my male readers that enjoy creepypasta and men. or maybe some females who like reading this stuff whatever the reason enjoy

  • Slender And His Proxies x Male!Reader
    146K 5.2K 53

    Ok, updating this.. You are a 24 year old human male with an odd condition of your bones hardening. What once was just a little accident caused from a tall entity at the treeline when you were younger had you being dragged away from your home and family to be placed into some facility to be tested for your condition...

    Mature
  • Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios (Male Reader)
    918K 15.5K 77

    So, I'm bored and saw more of these female scenarios than male. Might as well give it a try. Basically, for male readers but anyone can read it. Enjoy gentlemen or anyone reading this.

  • Jeff the killer X Male Reader
    104K 2.9K 38

    M/n was the average bullied sleep deprived boy in his school. Everything about him was normal, they is except for him knowing a certain murder.

  • The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader
    226K 6.7K 15

    (M/N). A young boy who is unable to speak. Not able to make a sound. To make up for it he has amazing art skills. His parents hated it. They didn't want to pay for lessons to speak.They wanted a child who could talk. Not someone who "waists their time on childish things like drawing." They didn't want to have this...

    Completed  
  • Beautiful Masks (Masky x Male Reader)
    18.3K 575 33

    After your dad went missing you ran away, knowing the police would give you back to your emotionally abusive mother and her new husband who made it a hobby to assault you. But when you ran away you never expected for a local myth to find you and listen to your story. You would soon join a group of murderers he took in...

    Mature
  • Bloody Weather [ Creepypasta x Male Reader ]
    204K 6.4K 28

    Will you try to make life better? -------------------------------------------- Status: On Hold for a few month (be back around October hopefully) and under-construction - meaning this story gets better and better over time #4 creepypastaxmalereader (3-5-22) #162 Gore (2-14-22) #6 creepypasta (11-4-22) #184 Killer (3-1...

    Mature
  • into the darkness (eyeless jack x male reader)
    10.7K 440 14

    Your best friend moved out of town when you were twelve. The two of you lost touch after that, but you never stopped thinking about him. Were you expecting to see him again in university? No. But you did. And the bond between you two only grew stronger after that. Until you find him laying in the forest at night, bloo...

  • Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios
    47.5K 972 27

    Heads up this is a gay boyfriend scenario book. If your not gay but your like "I'm not gay but if I was I'd date him" then your still welcome here! Hell everyone's welcome! Characters: Jeff the killer Eyeless Jack Masky Hoodie Ben And my OC Nate If you don't understand how this works here ya go: I write the story in k...

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios (male reader)
    64.6K 1.4K 11

    There's not many male reader creepypasta boyfriend scenarios, so I decided to write one myself. I hope you enjoy it.

  • Empty Canvas (Bloody painter x Male Reader)
    70.6K 2.1K 12

    Of course Helen paid no mind to you, he always kept to himself in his sketchbook drawing away like nothing else mattered. You always pushed yourself to become friends with the boy since you've admired his art. -I do not own the character Bloody painter-

  • Laughing Jack x Male!reader
    113K 4.9K 64

    I have no clue where im going with the plot but i promise its gonna be good.

    Mature
  • Silence | Jeff the Killer x Mute Male Reader
    225K 6.7K 32

    After your brother gets killed in front of you, you start getting taunted and manipulated by the man that killed your brother.

    Completed  
  • Into The Woods (Yandere Masky x Male Reader)
    43.1K 1.4K 26

    A young college student gets himself a stalker. How will he deal with it, and what's with the shy kid at school? Warning; contains cursing, violence, sex scenes, and mentions of rape. Read at your own risk.

    Mature
  • Life With Creepypastas - Creepypastas X Reader
    873K 22.2K 79

    ↳ ❝ when a mysterious faceless stick tree man believes you, a random wimpy teenager, is worthy enough to be one of his epic edgy sidekicks and murder people for touching his poor quality emo sketch book pages he leaves on trees. ❞ ⊹₊⋆☁︎⋆⁺₊⋆Life With Creepypastas [LWCPS]⋆⁺₊⋆☁︎⋆₊ ⊹ • 𝘯𝘰𝘯-𝘴𝘦𝘳�...

  • toby x Male reader (Complete)
    89.1K 2.3K 13

    "What are you hiding?" asked Toby with an eyebrow raised. M/n bit his lip and looked away from him "that's something you have to figure out yourself"

    Completed  
  • Serene And Gentle: A Creepypasta Fanfic
    27.8K 1K 25

    [ VARIOUS! Creepypasta X MALE! Reader/OC ] Warning: Mature Content, Triggering Scenes Calm is the forest right after the dawn light has kissed the colors into being. Just being there brings the soul into sweet surrender, at one with nature, vibrant yet relaxed. Every fragrance is fresh, like the page of a new book. Ea...

    Mature
  • A 'Different' Kind of Love // Jeff the Killer x Male! Reader
    164K 4.5K 33

    Y/n was an average high school student, he was the bullied introvert with no friends. His family kicked him out because he was gay. He was lonely. But little did he know a know a certain killer wanted to be his friend. 42 🏅 - #xmalereader 741🏅- #killer 202🏅- #boyxboy 23 🏅- #jeffthekiller 165 🏅 - #malereader 243 �...

    Completed