Carter Nicholas is the so-called "King of the Kings" at Beverly Hills High. He comes to believe his charming good looks and popularity can get him through almost anything until his life is chaotically upturned. It seems the only person who can help him is a girl he meets in the strangest of ways, who strives to enlighten someone in him whom he never even knew existed.

Aria has always laid low in school with her tight-knit group of friends. When she meets Nash at a party, he's rude, he's blunt, and he's got more baggage than he can carry. Aria immediately dislikes him. But the line between hate and love is very thin, and a continuous game of Never Have I Ever may change everything.