Keefe Sencen comes up with an incredible way to prank Tam Song by writing the male love letters and sticking them in his locker. The prank backfires as the more Keefe writes to Tam, the more he falls for the Shade.

Alastor and Lucifer try to get along once the hotel is rebuilt, but things happen that make things ever more difficult. What will Lucifer do with the things that he learns about the demon? Then a new guest comes and rumors start to spread. Whatever shall the demon do in order to keep up appearances?