The CreepyPasta BF Scenarios

Sorry! This is my first scenario thing. I'm new to this!

Kitty or Candy? *LJ x Reader*

I was a science experiment. I was created in secret by a scientist. I am half-cat-half-human. I can change from cat to human and vise versa. I HATE the lab where I am kept strapped up. Being tortured and tested. I am slowly loosing sanity, plotting my means of escape. Sweet, sweet freedom...

Dark Link x Reader (old and outdated)

cw for sexual assault. incredibly old and heavy topics not properly handled.

Zelda (Ben drowned X reader)

I don't believe in the paranormal. Especially not if they exist in a game. Ben isn't real... it's just some hacker messing around with me. Or even worse , a stalker... but still... judging by the things that happen around me, it doesn't seem like they could be done even by the smartest human being.

A deadly love (Ticci-Toby x reader)

Best Friends(Laughing Jack X Reader)

Life is fun. And fun is Laughing Jack. The monochrome killer clown is known for killing children for his own amusement, until one day he meets a rather extraordinary girl who leaves a scar on both of their souls.

{ lights out}Ticci Toby x Reader

knowing Toby Rodgers will not be a happy ending, there's too much broken, too much to fix. How is someone suppose to forgive all the things he's done wrong, and accept the little done right? Simply accepting the existence of him is accepting failure, in keeping him sane, and yourself safe.

Bitter sweet (LJ x reader)

Smile Dog ~ Love story

A girl named Alissa Meet smile at the mansion and smile has a crush on her but he doesn't wanna tell her. But he also can't becuse of her dad

Even if I scare you, I still love you. (Try at Smile Dog X reader)

Ok its a start tell me if you want more cause its just a start. Tell me what you think. Stupid,good,ok whatever. Just tell me

My Creeps.

ASK AND DARE THE CREEPYPASTA'S WHATEVER YOU GUYS FEEL LIKE IT! And of Course, you Guys can Ask me (Aka Jenny) Anything You Guys Want~ ANYTHING~ XD You Can Ask: Jenny The Killer. Jeff The Killer. Carnage/Aaron. BEN Drowned. Jane Everlasting/The Killer. Slenderman. Sally. Eyeless Jack. Laughing Jack. Dr. Smiley. Smi...

Kitten and Yarn. (Eyeless Jack, Sequel.)

***SEQUEL TO CYBER LOVE, BEN DROWNED*** Kitten, deaf child of Ben Drowned and Jenevee Lynn. Her mother was thought to have died in birth and Kitten was created. Jack was always interested in the baby, while she was still in her mothers stomach, and when she was born, they grew up to be good friends, until a different...

PASTA X READER ((SO MANY LEMONS!))

Read at your own risk! ----- Slenderman Ben Drowned Jeff The Killer Masky Hoodie Smile Dog Laughing Jack Eyeless Jack Homicidal Liu Lost Silver Ticci Toby Herobrine Etc... ----- Thanks for 131K Reads, really REALLY appreciate you all! Love you guys!

Ticci-Toby x reader

I've turned this book into a oneshot book rather than a full story, but in the future look forward to some full-length stories xD The old chapters are still there, though!

I don't mind your tics (Ticci-toby x Reader)

Just read it

Blood Flow (Jeff the Killer Love Story)

A murdered father has left Hope's life in shambles. With limited support in her life she feels alone. So what happens when a mysterious man comes into her life and flips it around?

Smile X Misty Smile Dog Love Story

This is about a dog called Misty falling for the creepypasta Smile dog.

Ticci Toby Romance...

Leah is a 17 year old girl, starving for danger, but when she comes face to face with the danger she was never expecting, how will she react?

Ticci Toby x Reader

You are in love, with Ticci Toby. The same boy who murdered your family. Are you really in love, or just crazy.

Electric - Ben Drowned Love Story

Electric is a Ben Drowned Love Story based on a 13 year old girl and Ben Drowned. "Y-you love me right?" I asked, my trembling lips shaking with each word. "Say anything more and my sword will be covered with your flesh and blood before you know it" he smirked. My eyes widened at the thought. "Would you really...

interesting piece of artwork: Ticci toby x Reader

CreepyPasta X Werewolf!Reader - Vexation

You, a half human, half werewolf, are not what you would expect of a werewolf. When you get bored of your once, horrible and easy life, you have a bit of 'over-exaggerated' fun with some very weird 'people'. In a turn of events, you end up befriending them, experiencing things you never felt or seen. However, your pas...

Laughing Jack X Candy maker!Reader(Temp.Discontinued)

You are FN and you own a candy store in a small secluded village. Everything seems like normal but what happens when the circus comes to town? A Laughing a Jack X reader Warning! Will contain strong language, possible rape and all around adult themes.

The Girl Who Everyone Ignored: A JTK X READER

THE GIRL WHO EVERYONE IGNORED: A JTK X READER. New version is out! https://www.wattpad.com/story/56892038-darkness-a-jeff-the-killer-x-reader-story

Love Kills : A Jimmy Casket X Reader X Johnny Ghost Fanfiction

(GOING THROUGH MAJOR EDITING) Jimmy casket...the infamous killer is a merciless killer who will do anything to quench his thirst for blood, but what happens when a certain girl has quench said thirst? your name is (f/n) (l/n), and this is your story of a killer who stole your heart.

Dagger's pain (Ticci Toby love story)

Dagger meets Toby and the rest of the creepypasta's. She starts to fall in love with Toby and Toby starts to fall in love with her, her father the devil himself tells her that she can't fall in love but I mean who listens to their fathers anyway. Many things happen that people would never even wish on their enemy's no...

Killers on the loose

Eternity Winters was never normal. Her eyes were black pools that had no color in them, her hair was midnight black, and her skin was a sickly purplish white. After killing her mother, she ran away with her best friend known as: Jane The Killer. But, while running in the woods she come upon Slendy and Jeff who decided...

Ask Tails Doll

Ask little Tails Doll, plz Tails Doll: Ask me anything!!!!!!! >:D

Creepypasta x Reader

This is an x reader story with the Creepypastas! Including Ben, Slenderman, Jeff the Killer, Lost Silver, Eyeless Jack, Laughing Jack, and more to come! Either going to be a romance or just a normal reader insert.

The Glitch In Our Love

After many happy years of their marriage, Eternity and Ben are still deeply in love. But, when Ben misunderstands something that he hears, he leaves Eternity and their child, Dustin. Eternity goes back to her old ways and begins to kill again, and everything is different. Finally, she decides to go to the world of Zel...