Kristine's life went as it usually did... Wake up, go to school, embarrass oneself at school, come home, hide from the world, repeat the next day. It was all normal... that was until he came into her life. Brendon, the witty, charming, sophisticated- and not to mention older- new next door neighbor. Being in a band and incredibly smart, he was everything Kristine has ever wanted. He was perfect (in her eyes, anyway) But when secrets are revealed, and promises aren't kept. Her perfect man may not be who she thought he was.

All my life I was taught that God had a plan for me. But this time he didn't. This boy was slowly turning me into the sinner I had always been afraid of.

24 year old college senior Alaina goes to a Fall Out Boy concert with her little sister on their Save Rock and Roll tour. Her night takes a twist when she goes to the bathroom and runs into 26 year old Brendon Urie, which she didn't know was the lead singer of Panic! at the time. When she goes backstage and meets Brendon again, will her perfect planned out life go as she expected?

You can't make a Church Boy out of an Atheist, but you can make a Bad Girl out of a Christian. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ A Brendon Urie Fanfic