Hello, this is the story of (y/n) (y/l/n) and what she's going through, The poor girl is having difficulty with two boys the first, a not so imaginary friend and the second? A charming toy maker but there's a problem (y/n) doesn't know who to chose and they both love her.

knowing Toby Rodgers will not be a happy ending, there's too much broken, too much to fix. How is someone suppose to forgive all the things he's done wrong, and accept the little done right? Simply accepting the existence of him is accepting failure, in keeping him sane, and yourself safe.

MATURE CONTENT 18+

Ft. Slenderman, Eyeless Jack, Jeff the Killer, Laughing Jack, & BEN Drowned. (Reader x Male Creepypasta). Msg me if you want any other creepypastas in this boyfriend scenarios!!!!!