Select All
  • Snow (Eyeless Jack X Reader)
    212K 7K 11

    (1st place winner of the Eyeless Jack category of the Fall 2016 Creepypasta Awards somehow, I don't feel like it's worthy of 1st but it's appreciated) It's getting close to the Christmas season. Snow glitters in the golden winter sunset. You only want 2 things this year. An escape from your abusive father, and the kin...

    Completed  
  • [DISCONTINUED] Codes of the Heart (BEN DrownedxReader)
    29.7K 942 7

    He knew all the codes. Every cheat. Every digit. Every little number. But he didn't know the codes of the heart. He NEEDED to know the codes of the heart. And she gave him just that. ((Cover art by: Gatanii69))

  • The Boy You Never Knew
    2.1K 67 3

    A Ticci-Toby x Reader! I guess I felt like making this one, since I was interested in Ticci-Toby. Description: It was in the middle of the night and you were craving for pancakes. You got the pancake mix out of the cupboard, got a couple cups of water, and a bowl. You poured the water into the pancake mix and started...

  • Ticci Toby x reader -DISCONTINUED-
    18.3K 690 20

    You are walking down an ally and you meet a stranger waring a mask and orange googles. His name is ticci Toby. -DISCONTINUED-

    Completed  
  • Hacked -Ticci Toby x Reader-
    1K 31 2

    You were an ordinary girl before the accident. Then something just... wasn't there anymore.. replaced by these bottled up emotions about your life, you'd snapped.

  • BEN DROWNED X Reader
    140K 1.8K 5

    WARNING: contains sexual content, don't like it then turn back now!

  • After Us (Ticci-Toby x Reader)
    7.2K 228 17

    "We belong in what comes after us."

    Completed  
  • Your ticks.
    74.6K 2K 8

    Ticci Toby x Reader Update 4/13/2023 Omg I wrote this book a longgggg time ago and then I lost my log in information back then. I can't believe so many people read this lmao. It has so many errors and it's so rushed I'm glad some of you enjoyed it though!

    Completed  
  • Eyeless jack x reader
    149K 4.6K 35

    You were just walking threw the woods and you had your knife with you. for some reason you chose to bring your smallest knife. also, for some reason, you were carving operator signs on trees. I guess its because it was Oct 13, Creepypasta day. on your third carving, you slit your finger by accident, causing blood to g...

  • Ticci Toby X READER
    78.1K 2.6K 11

    You're in an asylum, for something not entirely your fault. All you did was kill the bastard that murdered your mother all those years ago. oh, and that asylum? It's a girls only.. so how the hell did Toby get in?

  • Eyeless Love (Eyeless Jack X Reader)
    17.7K 434 4

    Your a simple, normal, teenage girl. Your a song writer and a singer. You love creepypasta and had always found Eyeless Jack as your favorite. You live a happy life, and have a happy family. One dark night, Your sleeping and you have a strange encounter. You meet face to face, with a young man, who happens to be, the...

  • BEN DROWNED x reader
    53.1K 2.2K 31

    A girl (You) liked to read creepypastas then one she recently read about stalks her. Romance sprange between the two and they loved each other till the end. BD + (Y/N)

  • Cuddling? [BEN Drowned x Reader]
    11.8K 214 1

    Just a BEN x Reader QuQ

    Completed  
  • Haunted (BEN drowned X Reader)
    12.3K 311 6

    An impulsive comment on cleverbot leads you into a interesting situation.

  • Do You Remember? (Eyeless Jack x Reader Romance)
    271K 5.5K 23

    Jack goes out to hunt and just so happens to run into you while you're out taking a walk. After Jack hurts you considerably, he decides to help you live. For what reason? You have no idea. Now, you're stuck at the Creepypasta mansion until you recover. But what happens when you learn that there's more to the killer th...

  • Ticci Toby x Reader
    151K 4.3K 22

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby x Reader
    126K 3.4K 16

    You know...

  • Eyeless Jack X Reader
    107K 2.6K 11

    One day when (y/n) sleeps she meets a CP named BEN DROWNED. He takes her to her unknown parents to meet for the first time. That's not the only thing (y/n) meets, (y/n) finds a true love in this creepy place her parents call 'home'......

    Completed  
  • Forever...(Ticci Toby X Reader)
    34.2K 999 6

    You Leave your house, never wanting to go back. Your mom hates you, she cuts and punches you all the time. No one knows, you cry yourself to sleep every night. You run deep into the woods and never return, who will you meet...? Who knows until you read!

    Completed  
  • Memories (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    1K 18 4

    Toby x Reader

  • [STOP READING THIS FOR THE LOVE OF GOD]Love With No Eyes (Eyeless Jack x Reader)
    74.3K 1.6K 11

    LITERALLY STOP READING THIS IT IS ACTUAL GARBAGE AND YOU COULD BE READING THINGS 100× BETTER. I don't know how anyone could be entertained by writing this fucking terrible. Please go find something else to do with your time rather than reading and commenting on this. (No I will not fucking update)

  • My Twitching Boyfriend {Ticci Toby x reader}
    746K 16.1K 33

    Being in the mansion is tough, ben being a pervert, jeff being a cry baby about losing, and the MISSIONS but when a friend you haven't seen comes along...the world changes and things don't seem that bad until later on

    Completed   Mature
  • Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    1.6M 51.5K 37

    A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderm...

    Completed  
  • The Monster Within
    4K 180 12

    A monster. That's what they whispered. Cannibal. That's what the saw. But can they really blame you? You're not like them, after all...

  • Love Doesn't Drown (BEN DROWNED X READER)
    129K 3.7K 5

    Your a teenage girl gamer. You beat everyone at every game you knew. You have a bit of sadness inside for only one reason. Your father left. One day you get a small package with a game you've never heard of. As you play the strange game....something strange happens...